'Judge Serving The Master': Criminal Contempt Plea In Delhi High Court Against CJP Legal Head Ratna Singh Over X Posts On Saket CJM
| CJP's Ratna Singh faces a criminal contempt plea in the Delhi High Court for saying a Saket judge was "serving the master", and the Delhi Government's Law Officer has backed it
Contempt plea against Ratna Singh says calling a judge a "master's" servant attacks judicial independence, not merely the order
A practising advocate has moved the Delhi High Court to initiate criminal contempt proceedings against Ratna Singh, who describes herself on X as a lawyer and the Legal Affairs Head of the Cockroach Janta Party (CJP), over posts alleging that a Saket Chief Judicial Magistrate was acting at the behest of a "master".
The petition, dated November 16, comes armed with the written consent of Amol Sinha, Additional Standing Counsel (Criminal), Government of NCT of Delhi, who has opined that the imputations "prima facie attract the provisions of Section 2(c)(i) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971".
The petitioner, Advocate Kausik Chatterjee, a member of the Delhi High Court Bar Association, has invoked Article 215 of the Constitution read with Sections 2(c), 10 and 15 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, and the Contempt of Courts (Delhi High Court) Rules, 2025. He states that he has "no personal interest or other stake in the matter" and was not a party to the proceedings that gave rise to the posts.
The petition has been filed through Advocates Samridhi Solanki and Megha Aggarwal of K Chatterjee Legal Consultants LLP.
The posts: "Judge serving the master"
According to the petition, proceedings instituted by Singh came up on October 10, 2026 before Abhinav Pandey, Chief Judicial Magistrate, South-East District, Saket Courts. The Law Officer's opinion records that the proceedings related to Singh's alleged detention by the Delhi Police and that the order passed that day declined the relief she had sought.
Thereafter, the petition says, Singh posted from her handle @wattalawyer: "Judge serving the master. Went for break/meeting 4 times during entire hearing. Order without any application of law."
In a second post, she wrote: "@DelhiPolice is following order from master. Judge is following order from master."
It states that the petitioner "does not question the right of the Respondent to criticise a judicial order or to express dissatisfaction with the manner in which judicial proceedings were conducted", and that the plea "is not founded upon the Respondent's criticism of the order or her statement concerning interruptions during the hearing."
The objection is confined to the allegation that the judicial officer was serving or following a "master". The petition contends, these statements "suggest that the learned Judicial Officer was acting under the influence or directions of an unidentified external authority, rather than exercising his judicial functions independently and in accordance with law." Such an allegation, "when publicly made without any disclosed factual foundation, is capable of lowering the authority of the Court and undermining public confidence in the administration of justice."
In its grounds, the petition adds that the posts identify the officer through the proceedings he conducted and so "cannot be treated merely as general comments concerning the functioning of the judicial system", and that Singh "did not disclose … any factual basis" for the "master" allegation.
Chatterjee first wrote to the Standing Counsel (Criminal), GNCTD on October 14 and filed a supplementary representation on October 28. In his opinion dated November 2, the Additional Standing Counsel framed the question thus: "The question is not whether the words are discourteous or offensive to a Judicial Officer; the question is whether they prima facie constitute a publication scandalising, or tending to scandalise or lower, the authority of a Court within the meaning of Section 2(c)(i) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971…"
Relying on P.N. Duda v. V.P. Shiv Shankar, he accepted that fair criticism of judicial functioning is permissible, but held, "However, a clear distinction exists between questioning the correctness of a judicial decision and attributing extraneous influences or improper motives to the Judicial Officer responsible for rendering such decision. In the present case, the statements that the Judge was 'serving the master' and 'following order from master' are not confined to the merits of the order or the manner in which the proceedings were conducted."
Such allegations, "when made publicly against an identifiable Judicial Officer in connection with proceedings conducted by him, are prima facie capable of lowering the authority of the Court and undermining public confidence in the administration of justice," the opinion reads. It further notes that while circulation "cannot by itself constitute criminal contempt", public dissemination is "a relevant circumstance".
Posts on Delhi Police and SEM courts held to be strong criticism, not contempt
The supplementary representation placed on record Singh's later statements: an October 16 X post on the Delhi Police ("Aap chronology samajhiye … Waah re Delhi Police!"), remarks carried by the Press Trust of India on October 19 that "SEM (Special Executive Magistrate) courts should be abolished because the system is compromised", and an October 22 post stating "I reiterate." It also relied on an October 21 order of the Special Executive Magistrate (SEM) in the proceedings involving CJP members Saurav Das and Ashutosh Ranka, which recorded a police objection to a media statement and an unconditional verbal apology tendered by counsel.
The Law Officer declined to rest his consent on this material. He found that the subsequent publications "are principally directed against the conduct of the Delhi Police and the functioning of the Special Executive Magistrate system" and "cannot be treated as criminal contempt merely because they express strong criticism of those authorities." He also noted that the October 21 order "does not record any personal apology or undertaking by Ms. Ratna Singh, nor any finding of contempt against her." His opinion in favour of initiation, he said, "rests independently upon the earlier publications" concerning the CJM.
He accordingly accorded consent for "taking appropriate steps towards initiation of criminal contempt proceedings" under Section 15(2), while clarifying that the opinion "shall not be construed as a final determination of criminal contempt, which shall remain subject to the independent consideration of the Hon'ble High Court."
The grounds set out why, in the petitioner's view, the posts cross the line from criticism into contempt. Ground A reads, "BECAUSE the statements complained of do not merely express disagreement with a judicial order. By alleging that the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate was serving or following a "master", the Respondent attributed the exercise of judicial functions to an unidentified external authority, thereby questioning the independence and impartiality of the learned Judicial Officer. Such an imputation is capable of creating an impression that judicial decisions are controlled by persons outside the judicial process, thereby undermining the authority of the Court and public confidence in the administration of justice, rather than merely affecting the personal reputation of the Judicial Officer."
Ground B contends that the posts were "directed at an identifiable Court and its Presiding Officer in relation to the discharge of judicial functions" and "cannot be treated merely as general comments concerning the functioning of the judicial system." Ground C treats the use of a public platform as relevant, since the statements "were capable of reaching persons having no direct knowledge of the judicial proceedings or the circumstances in which the order was passed."
Ground D turns on the absence of any basis for the allegation, "BECAUSE the Respondent did not disclose, in the publications complained of, any factual basis for alleging that the learned Judicial Officer was acting under the instructions of a "master". The allegation was presented as a statement concerning the conduct of the Judicial Officer rather than as a question regarding the correctness of his order. The absence of any disclosed foundation is material when assessing the nature and effect of the imputation."
Ground E submits that these factors, "considered together, disclose a prima facie case requiring examination under Section 2(c)(i) read with Section 13(a)" and that the posts "have a tendency to substantially interfere with the administration of justice by undermining public confidence in the independence and impartiality of the subordinate judiciary."
Prayers Sought
The petitioner has prayed that the High Court "Take cognizance of the publications complained of herein as constituting prima facie criminal contempt within the meaning of Section 2(c)(i) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, and initiate appropriate criminal contempt proceedings against the Respondent, Ms. Ratna Singh, in accordance with law". In the alternative, he has asked the Court to "exercise its suo motu criminal contempt jurisdiction under Article 215 of the Constitution of India read with Section 10 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, take cognizance of the publications complained of herein and initiate appropriate criminal contempt proceedings against the Respondent", together with such further orders as the Court may deem fit.
Case Title: Kausik Chatterjee v. Ratna Singh
Bench: Delhi High Court (hearing expected)