Petitioner tells Supreme Court that the ECI's unanimous affidavit does not prove its SIR decisions were unanimous

The Election Commission of India (ECI) cannot defend its decisions on the Special Intensive Revision (SIR) by pointing to a unanimous affidavit, the petitioner in the challenge to the Commission's internal decision-making has told the Supreme Court. "Unanimity in defending an act is not unanimity in deciding it," he has said, contending that the ECI's own admissions on oath show that key steps were taken by officers and divisions without any decision of the three-member Commission under Section 18 of the Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners (Appointment, Conditions of Service and Term of Office) Act, 2023.

The submissions are made in a consolidated rejoinder affidavit filed by Rakesh Kumar Singh alias Rakesh Singh in Rakesh Kumar Singh alias Rakesh Singh v. Union of India & Ors through Advocate-on-Record (AoR) Mudit Gupta.

The affidavit answers both the ECI's counter affidavit of October 26 and its supplementary affidavit of November 14, in terms of the liberty granted by the Court on October 27. The petition concerns the functioning of Chief Election Commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, who is arrayed as Respondent No. 3, and is before a Bench of Chief Justice of India Surya Kant and Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana.

The ECI had argued that the petition rested only on a newspaper report. It points out that the counter affidavit was, in the ECI's own words, "approved for filing … by a unanimous decision of the three members of the Election Commission". From this it argues: "Those admissions bind all three members, including Respondent No. 3, and the Writ Petition no longer depends on newspaper reportage."

The petitioner frames the case as raising "one narrow and fundamental question", whether acts done in the Commission's name were decisions of the Commission "taken unanimously or, upon difference of opinion, by majority, as mandated by Article 324(1) to (3) of the Constitution and Sections 17 and 18" of the 2023 Act, "or whether they were taken by one member, or by officers and divisions of the Secretariat, without any such decision."

He lists what he calls the respondents' own admissions. They include steps taken by officers "which needed to be corrected to ensure that they are fully aligned with the steps approved by the Election Commission", an SIR declaration "entered into the online page of Form 6" in a way that "could be construed as though an amendment of Form 6 had been made", and an internal work order of July 28, 2026 issued by an officer on deputation that was "never implemented" only because the two Election Commissioners jointly directed so.

On the law, the rejoinder argues that Article 324 vests power in "a Commission", not in its Chairman. It relies on the Constitution Bench ruling in T.N. Seshan v. Union of India (1995), which it says rejected the view that Election Commissioners are advisers whose opinions the CEC may override, since treating his word as final would render them "non-functional or ornamental".

Responding to the ECI's description of how files move from one Election Commissioner to the other "and then finally to the Chief Election Commissioner", the petitioner says, "The Election Commission is not a 'chain of command'. The Election Commissioners are Members of a multi-member constitutional body and are not subordinates of its Chairman." He adds that Section 18 "recognises only two modes of decision-making" and "does not recognise a decision by whichever Member signs last."

Applying this to Form 6, the rejoinder states that one Election Commissioner recorded on 16 May 2026, and the other concurred on 19 May, that Form 6 could not lawfully be altered without amending the Rules. "Two of three members are a majority. Yet the alteration was implemented in July 2026 and remained until 21.10.2026." Only two explanations are possible, it says: either "the majority opinion was overridden by the member at the end of the file chain, in direct breach of Section 18(2)", or "the alteration was made without any decision of the Commission at all". "On either hypothesis the act was not the act of the Commission."

The ECI's description of members' notings as "suggestions", "observations" or "queries", the petitioner argues, "cannot alter the statutory consequence of a recorded difference of opinion."

The petitioner clarifies that his grievance is not that the printed Form 6 was amended. His case is that in July 2026 the online form was altered so that an applicant could not proceed without answering whether he, his parents or grandparents "exist" in the last SIR roll, although the Registration of Electors Rules, 1960 prescribe no such field.

He rejects the ECI's convenience explanation of "a single OTP and single e-sign", saying it "finds no contemporaneous basis in any order or decision of the Commission". Relying on Mohinder Singh Gill, he argues that administrative action "cannot be supplemented by fresh justifications in an affidavit." The petitioner puts a pointed question: "If an applicant submits Form 6 but does not submit the additional Declaration, will the Form 6 still be accepted and processed, or will the application itself be treated as incomplete or invalid? If the latter, the additional Declaration effectively becomes compulsory, even though it is not part of the statutory Form 6."

On technology, it says the Commission's IT establishment, "which is not a statutory authority under the 1950 Act, cannot by software configuration override or nullify the statutory decisions of EROs, as happened in Goa. An IT system is a means of discharging statutory functions; it cannot become a source of power." On Goa, the petitioner says the ECI has not denied that the CEO's office sent eight communications between 11 and 17 February 2026 seeking a facility to record the EROs' decisions on 97 electors, which "was not enabled before final publication of the electoral roll."

The rejoinder sets out eleven measures placed on record by the ECI, all taken after the newspaper report of September 22, 2026 and most after the petition was filed on September 27. They include the Form 6 clarification of 3 November, the IT work order of 4 November and the ASDD directions of 6 November.

"That these measures are welcome as far as they go. But they are, in law and in fact, admissions that the matters raised were real. They do not render the Writ Petition infructuous," the petitioner says. He argues that they do not answer "the anterior question of who authorised the original acts", that several were themselves issued by officers without any pleaded decision of the Commission, and that "a void act is not validated by later correction or ratification", citing Marathwada University v. Seshrao Balwant Rao Chavan.

The ECI's supplementary affidavit had said that its IT/ICT Division "has always remained under the supervision of a DEC". The petitioner relies on the new allocation to a Senior DEC but says the claim of continuous supervision "is denied, being contrary to the Respondents' own averments in paragraph 32 of the Counter Affidavit and the admitted letters addressed by the two Election Commissioners to the Cabinet Secretary". In any event, he says, "supervision of a Division by an individual officer cannot be equated with a decision of the Commission as a multi-member body."

He also notes that the work order of November 4, is signed "By Order" by the Principal Secretary, and that no agenda, minutes, file notings or electronic approval showing the Commission's decision has been produced.

On the November 3 clarification that previously enrolled electors would not be prosecuted under Section 31 of the Representation of the People Act, 1950 for filing Form 6, the rejoinder says the clarification "acknowledges the difficulty created by requiring existing electors to follow the route prescribed for fresh applicants." It adds that the clarification does not explain why such electors were omitted from the draft roll in the first place, and that it is signed by an Under Secretary with no Commission decision produced.

The petitioner treats the 6 November directions for electors marked Absent, Shifted, Dead or Duplicate (ASDD) as a corrective measure. He argues that the "reassignment of the same EPIC number recognises that the persons concerned may be existing electors whose earlier electoral particulars already existed, and not fresh applicants."

His sharper objection is to their reach. Annexure R-17 "is addressed only to the CEOs of NCT of Delhi, Maharashtra, Haryana, Andhra Pradesh, Jharkhand, Telangana and Nagaland", whereas the ECI's own counter affidavit says the SIR is ongoing in 16 States and 3 Union Territories. "Electors in the 13 States and Union Territories where the SIR is complete … receive no comparable opportunity," the rejoinder says.

Answering the ECI's acknowledgment that "there have been and will be problems", the petitioner says: "Purity of the electoral roll and inclusion of eligible electors are complementary obligations; neither can be pursued at the cost of the other."

On the appeals filed before the West Bengal Appellate Tribunals, the petitioner relies on the ECI's admission that they were filed by officers of the CEO, West Bengal and that "these matters were not brought to the Commission." He argues that under Section 13CC of the 1950 Act these officers work under the Commission's superintendence, direction and control, so "The Commission cannot disclaim knowledge of appeals filed by officers who are by law under its control".

He points out that the newspaper report records 16.10 lakh appeals against electors whose names had been included in the rolls, a figure he says "has not been specifically denied", and that the ECI has not disclosed "who authorised the filing of these appeals, the criteria adopted, or the number of cases in which such decisions were taken."

Addressing the ECI's objection to the prayer for quo warranto, the petitioner says he "has never questioned the appointment of Respondent No. 3" and "does not seek the removal" of the CEC. His challenge, he says, concerns the legality of acts done in the Commission's name. "Protection of tenure cannot be converted into immunity from judicial scrutiny," the rejoinder states. It also says that the petition "seeks to uphold the institution against the exercise of its powers by others in its name."

Directions sought by the Petitioner

The petitioner asks the Court to reject the preliminary objections raised in both ECI affidavits and to direct Respondent Nos. 2 to 5 to produce the original records, including agendas, minutes, file notings, circulation sheets and electronic approvals. These relate to the three SIR Orders, the office orders of September 23, 2025, July 28, 2026 and November 4, 2026, the letters to the Cabinet Secretary and the joint direction of July 30, 2026, the West Bengal appeals, the Goa correspondence on the 97 electors, and the introduction and later separation of the declaration in the online Form 6. He also seeks the report of the ECINet compliance committee, audit trails of changes to ECINet since October 1, 2025, and State-wise and constituency-wise data on ASDD electors and on forms received under the 6 November directions.

He further seeks an affidavit from a responsible officer identifying, for each impugned action, "the decision of the Commission relied upon, specifying its date, mode of approval and whether it was unanimous or by majority", or the specific delegation under which it was done. As an interim measure, he asks that, "pending final adjudication of the present Writ Petition, no communication, order, direction or appeal shall be issued or instituted in the name of the Election Commission except pursuant to a decision of the Commission recorded in accordance with Section 18 of the 2023 Act or under a specific and duly established delegation of authority".

The rejoinder also asks for disclosure of the period and States in which the additional declaration was part of the online Form 6, and of the number of applications rejected, kept pending or left incomplete in that period. It seeks a direction that the ASDD "restoration opportunity contemplated under Annexure R-17 be extended to similarly situated ASDD electors in every State/Union Territory where the SIR is ongoing or has been completed, subject to verification in accordance with law". The petitioner further asks that agendas be "circulated to all three Members of the Commission before meetings" with minutes recorded and circulated, that all files, access logs and audit trails be preserved, and that the Commission take a recorded Section 18 decision on whether the West Bengal appeals "are to be pursued".

The rejoinder closes with a summary of the petitioner's case, "That the Respondents have asserted unanimity but have not produced a single contemporaneous record of any decision of the Commission on any act impugned. They have instead admitted that officers took steps needing correction, that the online statutory form was altered, that an officer re-allocated the Commission's internal work, that IT modules were not placed before the Commission, and that appeals affecting lakhs of electors were filed without the matter being brought to the Commission. Those admissions are the admissions of all three members. An assertion of unanimity is not proof of it. Administrative practice is not statutory authority. Subsequent correction is not authorisation at the time of the act."

Background
Earlier, Supreme Court had urged the Election Commission of India to consider accepting late enumeration forms and extend the October 30 deadline for the Delhi SIR if needed. A CJI Surya Kant led bench had also asked the ECI to explain why voters already on the 2026 roll must file Form 6, which is meant for first-time voters, after about 43 lakh were left out of the draft roll as shifted or absent. ECI had said it will file a report in two weeks.

Advocate Prashant Bhushan had told court that out of 47 lakhs who did not fill the enumeration form ECI said 43 lakh are permanently shifted and two lakhs have died. "The problem is this, they gave the enumeration forms with the printed old address. Form 8 is for shifted voters, but ECI is saying they will have to fill up form 6. The form 6 contains a declaration that you have never voted before, which would be a false declaration," Bhushan had added.

The issue was originally flagged before Supreme Court by a few voters who were asked by the Election Commission to re-enroll under the Form-6 as the Special intensive Revision of Electoral Rolls in underway.

In the Delhi SIR petition, Supreme Court on September 22 had questioned the Election Commission of India over the manner in which notices were being issued to voters during the ongoing Special Intensive Revision of Delhi’s electoral rolls. Court heard a plea concerning notices issued to more than 33 lakh voters whose names have been flagged for either “no mapping” with the 2002 electoral roll or “logical discrepancies.”

The Court observed that the notices appeared to have been issued “almost mechanically” and sought clarification from the ECI on the basis for identifying voters under the “logical discrepancy” category. The Bench also sought details regarding the manpower deployed for the verification exercise.

The petition has been filed by activists Anjali Bhardwaj and Amrita Johri and argued by advocate Prashant Bhushan. It challenges the failure to disclose the names of voters who have been issued notices and the specific reasons for such notices. The petitioners have sought a searchable, consolidated list identifying all electors who received notices, along with the precise reason for each notice. They have also sought disclosure of the criteria, algorithmic parameters and operational guidelines used to identify “logical discrepancies.”

The Delhi SIR has generated significant attention after the draft electoral roll published on August 31, 2026 removed around 47.7 lakh names from the existing list of approximately 1.45 crore electors. The Election Commission said the enumeration phase resulted in forms being collected and uploaded for about 97.51 lakh electors. Those whose names are missing from the draft roll can file claims for inclusion between August 31 and September 30, along with the prescribed forms and supporting documents. The process also provides for verification and hearings where required. The Delhi SIR schedule has been revised three times. Under the latest timeline, the final electoral roll is scheduled to be published on November 4, 2026.

Case title: Rakesh Kumar Singh alias Rakesh Singh v. Union of India & Ors.

Bench: CJI Surya Kant, Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V. Mohana

Tags: