Central Vista: Supreme Court Records Centre’s Assurance Not To Move 135-Year-Old Library Till November 20
The Supreme Court recorded the Centre's assurance that the library would not be moved until the next hearing, after the Amicus Curiae reported a shortfall of space at the temporary premises and some 2 lakh books lying in cartons since 2011
Centre assures the Supreme Court that the Shastri Bhavan library will not be moved before the next hearing on 20 November
The Supreme Court on Monday called the authorities to account over the proposed relocation of a 135-year-old library at Shastri Bhavan, New Delhi, which holds about 8.5 lakh books, including heritage material dating back to 1702. The Bench recorded the Centre's assurance that no shifting would take place until the next date of hearing.
The Bench of Justices Sanjay Kumar and Sanjeev Sachdeva was hearing In Re: 135-Year-Old Library. The library is to be moved because the existing building is to be demolished. No permanent home has yet been identified for it under the Central Vista redevelopment.
Expressing displeasure with the way the authorities were handling the collection, Justice Kumar remarked, "If you don't want them, give it off to some other country which will at least value them then."
The Amicus Curiae informed the Bench that the authorities had floated a tender on 11 November for shifting the library, with 22 November as the last date for the process. She also pointed out that the authorities' affidavit indicated that the books were proposed to be moved to a temporary location by 26 November.
An applicant urged the Court to intervene before the shifting took place, contending that the proposed temporary premises might not have adequate space to accommodate the collection.
The Amicus told the Bench that she had personally inspected the existing library, the proposed temporary premises and one other location.
She submitted that the existing library at Shastri Bhavan occupies approximately 4,100 sq. metres, whereas the proposed temporary premises measure around 3,800 sq. metres. The usable space at the new site, she said, is considerably less, since portions of it are taken up by corridors, lift lobbies and other facilities.
The Amicus therefore sought a detailed comparative break-up of the space now used for bookshelves, racks and reading areas, set against the space proposed to be allotted at the temporary premises. She told the Court that two separate charts had been furnished but that neither gave the comparison needed of the actual space available for the library.
She also sought further details from the authorities, including the layout plans and a proper assessment of the space available at the proposed temporary location.
The Amicus drew the Court's attention to nearly 2 lakh books lying in cartons near the CAG office. Placing photographs before the Bench, she submitted that the books had remained in that condition since 2011, with some cartons still unopened and books scattered across the premises.
She asked why the authorities had not even verified the collection or prepared a proper catalogue of these books. She stressed that the collection was not merely a set of books but an important part of the country's heritage, with material dating back to 1702.
Justice Kumar questioned the authorities on the fate of these books, on the manner in which the entire exercise was being carried out, and on their approach to preserving the collection.
The concern was also voiced during the hearing that the authorities appeared to be adopting an ad hoc approach towards a collection of immense historical significance.
Additional Solicitor General (ASG) Aishwarya Bhati, appearing for the Centre, sought to distinguish the books lying near the CAG office from the Shastri Bhavan library.
She told the Court that these books belonged to the Tulsi Sadan Library and had been moved from the National School of Drama premises at Copernicus Marg, Mandi House, on account of metro-related work. She maintained that they formed a separate collection and were not the books covered by the present shifting exercise.
Justice Kumar questioned this distinction, observing that the two collections were originally part of the same library. The authorities were asked to clarify the origin and status of the Tulsi Sadan collection, and the Bench indicated that the factual position would have to be verified.
ASG Bhati submitted that the existing building has to be demolished and that the library would be given a permanent location once the new building comes up as part of the Central Vista development.
The Bench, however, made it clear that the immediate concerns over the books and their preservation could not be brushed aside.
ASG Bhati assured the Court that the additional information sought by the Amicus would be furnished along with the affidavit and its annexures. She further assured the Bench that the concerned officers would be informed and that no shifting would take place until the next hearing.
The Court directed that copies of the affidavit, together with the annexures and layout plans, be furnished to the applicant in the intervention application as well.
The matter will next be heard on November 20.
Background
The Central Secretariat Library, spread over four floors in Shastri Bhavan, houses more than 8.5 lakh books, including rare books, official records and gazetteers. It also receives visitors including government officials and students preparing for competitive examinations. The library's oldest book, kept in a separate rare books section, is a compilation of writings by a French traveller dating back to 1702.
The proposed relocation followed a September 17 communication from the Central Public Works Department to ministries and departments housed in Shastri Bhavan, asking them to vacate the complex along with furniture, electronic items and other belongings at the earliest. The CPWD said the building had to be handed over by the end of September 2026 for commencement of construction work.
According to reports, the Directorate of Estates had in January allotted two rooms measuring around 300 square metres at Kartavya Bhavan-2 for the Central Secretariat Library. The Ministry of Culture, which administers the library, had reportedly rejected the proposed space as inadequate.
Case Title: In Re: 135 year old library, 8.5 lakh books - and no room in the New Central Vista Plan
Bench: Justices Sanjay Kumar and Sanjeev Sachdeva
Hearing Date: November 16, 2026