A Stranger Is Not Allowed To Intrude Into Family Home: MP HC Lets Brother Buy Out Sibling’s Sold Share

Partition Act Protects Family Dwelling Houses From Outsiders, Rules MP High Court in Brothers’ Property Dispute
The Madhya Pradesh High Court at Gwalior has held that a brother who co-owns a family dwelling house must be given a chance to buy back the share his sibling sold to an outsider, setting aside two concurrent rulings that had thrown out his suit.
Justice Ashish Shroti, in a judgment delivered on 17 November 2026 in Arvind Kumar Rathore vs Harish Kumar Rathore and Another, found that the courts below had overlooked Section 4 of the Partition Act, 1893, a provision meant to keep strangers out of a family home.
The dispute concerns a double-storeyed house in Guna measuring 290.50 square feet. Originally owned by the brothers’ uncle and later sold to a third party, it was repurchased jointly by Arvind and Harish through a sale deed dated 2 November 1999.
In 2005, Harish sold his half, measuring 152.75 square feet, to respondent no. 2 for Rs 1,20,000. Arvind says he learnt of the sale only through a legal notice in March 2012. He sued, seeking a declaration that the sale deed was void and an injunction against interference with his possession. The buyer countered with a claim for title, partition and separate possession.
The trial court dismissed Arvind’s suit on 20 August 2014. The first appellate court affirmed that decision on 12 December 2019, holding that Section 22 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 did not apply because the house was not joint family property.
Why Section 4 of the Partition Act Came to the Brother’s Rescue
The High Court agreed that Section 22 was not attracted, since the brothers had bought the house rather than inherited it. The appeal, however, was admitted on a single question: whether the lower courts erred in not complying with Section 4 of the Partition Act.
The Court noted that the provision was framed for dwelling houses, “clearly with an intention that a stranger is not allowed to intrude into a house wherein the other shareholder is already residing.”
The Court listed five Section 4 conditions: a dwelling house belonging to an undivided family; a claimant who is a family member and shareholder; a share sold to a stranger; a partition suit filed by that stranger; and an undertaking by the claimant to buy the share. All but the last were met, since the buyer’s counter-claim sought partition.
On the missing undertaking, the Court relied on the Supreme Court’s ruling in Ghantesher Ghosh vs Madan Mohan Ghosh, which held Section 4 can be invoked even at the execution stage of a partition decree. Arvind had already filed his undertaking in the appeal.
The buyer argued that Arvind was changing his stand at the second appeal stage. The Court disagreed, observing his challenge to the sale deed rested on his preferential right to purchase, as pleaded in the plaint. “There is no shift of stand contrary to what is asserted in plaint,” it said, rejecting the doctrine of election argument as well. It also held that the buyer, being a stranger, cannot invoke Section 2 of the Act.
The nature of the house weighed too. Described as a kachcha construction of bricks and mud, it was “not susceptible to convenient partition by metes and bound.” Arvind, admittedly, resides there, and the house “is more beneficial for the residence of the plaintiff rather than defendant no.2, who is a stranger to the family.”
As execution proceedings for partition are still pending because of an interim order dated 22 February 2022, the Court chose not to remand the case. Instead, it directed Arvind to submit his undertaking before the executing court, which must value the share sold to the buyer and give him the option to purchase it at that valuation. The appeal was allowed, with parties bearing their own costs.
Advocate Faiz Ahmed Qureshi appeared for the appellant, while Siddharth Sijoria and Madhur Bhargava represented respondent no. 2.
Case Title: Arvind Kumar Rathore vs Harish Kumar Rathore and Another
Judgment Date: November 17, 2026
Bench: Justice Ashish Shroti
