‘Court Proceedings Are Not For Entertainment’: Allahabad HC Takes Serious View Of Unauthorised Courtroom Recording

Allahabad High Court directs custody of a man accused of recording court proceedings without permission.
X

Allahabad High Court acts against unauthorised courtroom recordings.

The Allahabad High Court single judge bench of Justice Vikarm D. Chauhan directed a man's custody after three unauthorised courtroom recordings were found on his phone, warning against social media broadcasts without court permission.

The Allahabad High Court on November 19, 2026 directed a man who allegedly recorded three videos of court proceedings without permission to be taken into custody and produced before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Prayagraj, while directing him to explain why the recording should not be treated as interference in the administration of justice.

Court observed that the principle of open justice does not authorise individuals to broadcast court proceedings on social media without permission, warning that unauthorised recordings could prejudice litigants and expose victims to social media stigma.

"The principle of open justice means proceedings are generally open to the public to attend. However, the same does not amount to "free broadcast" by any unauthorized individual," said the bench of Justice Vikram D. Chauhan.

Justice Chauhan stressed that "the court proceedings are not for entertainment purpose but is a serious business affecting liberty and rights of an individual".

Court emphasised that the publishing or recording judicial proceedings without leave of the court may have the effect of social media trial without even the final determination in the court proceedings and may adversely affect the court proceedings or the right of litigant.

"There may be prejudice caused to the persons, whose cases are being listed and argued before this court. The victims may also have to face social media stigma, if their facts or harassment is uploaded on the digital network," the single judge bench observed.

Therefore, taking a serious view, Justice Chauhan directed that litigants be prohibited from carrying mobile phones inside courtrooms, holding advocates responsible if their clients are found carrying phones during proceedings.

"It is for the advocates to strictly instruct their clients not to bring mobile phones into the courtroom. In this respect, a notice shall be pasted by the Registrar General of this court at the pass counter of the high court," court directed.

On November 19, court was dealing with a matter under Article 227 when, during the hearing, Additional Advocate General P.K. Singh informed the court that a person was recording court proceedings on his mobile phone without permission.

The person identified himself as Raj Kulshrestha. He admitted recording the proceedings without permission but could not explain why he had done so.

The Bench Secretary took custody of his mobile phone. Upon examination, three videos of court proceedings were found on it.

Raj Kulshrestha produced a pass issued by the Registry that permitted access only to the advocates' chamber. He had entered the courtroom without a proper pass. He also disclosed that he had no case listed before the court.

Kulshrestha stated that Bhanu Pratap Seth, a junior of advocate Nitish Kumar Soni, had brought him to the court.

Court noted that Nitish Kumar Soni was out of station and Bhanu Pratap Seth was absent when the matter was taken up. Court, however, directed both advocates to appear on November 20 and explain why proceedings should not be initiated against them for interference in the administration of justice.

Senior Advocate C.P. Upadhyaya, President, Allahabad High Court Bar Association, told the court that some advocates were recording and uploading videos of court proceedings and he had seriously objected to such conduct.

He also informed the court that he had circulated a notice prohibiting advocates from making or uploading reels, photographs and videos from the high court premises.

The notice prescribed a penalty of ₹5,000 and contemplated disciplinary action, including possible termination of Bar Association membership.

Court also directed Kuldeep Batra, whose petition was listed before it, to explain on affidavit why he had entered the courtroom carrying a pass meant only for access to the advocates' chambers. Batra told the court that he did not know Kulshrestha.

Explaining the need to regulate recording of judicial proceedings, court observed that it deals with several sensitive matters involving individual liberty, child sexual abuse, CBI investigations, Enforcement Directorate proceedings and cases concerning MPs and MLAs. Therefore, in view of the incident, court directed the Registrar (Protocol) to ensure that persons without proper passes were not permitted to enter courtrooms and to make the necessary endorsements on passes issued by the Registry.

Court further directed that Kulshrestha's mobile phone be kept in a sealed cover and produced before it the next day.

On November 20, advocate Nitish Kumar Soni appeared before the court and tendered an unconditional apology. Further, his junior, advocate Bhanu Pratap Seth, upon inquiry as to why he had not appeared on November 19, told the court that he was frightened and, as such, could not appear alone.

Kulshrestha also tendered an unconditional apology and gave an undertaking of maintaining the court decorum in future.

On Batra (the litigant in the matter at hand) having a pass allowing access only to the Advocate Chamber, court noted that advocate Soni stated that the error was on the part of his office in issuance of incorrect pass.

Taking note of these developments, court directed that the proceedings in this issue be dropped and ordered Kulshrestha to released from police custody forthwith.

However, court clarified that its directions restricting litigants from carrying mobile phones to the courtroom shall continue.

"The mobile phones may be kept in the office of the concerned Advocate or may be kept somewhere else. Accordingly, the Court proceedings are hereby dropped," Justice Chauhan concluded.

Case Title: Kuldeep Batra vs. State of U.P. and Another

Order Date: November 19, 2026

Bench: Justice Vikram D. Chauhan

Click here to download judgment

Tags

Next Story