MP HC Upholds Reconstituted State Transport Authority, Says No New Notification Needed When Chairman Changes

“Appointment and Nomination Are One and the Same Thing”: MP High Court Clears State Transport Authority Notification
The Madhya Pradesh High Court at Gwalior has upheld the State Government’s notification reconstituting the State Transport Authority, holding that nominating an Additional Chief Secretary or Principal Secretary-level officer as Chairman is within the power given by Section 68(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, and that a fresh notification is not needed every time the post changes hands.
A division bench of Justice G.S. Ahluwalia and Justice Anuradha Shukla dismissed the writ petition filed by Harishankar Singh Patel and others. It also recalled the interim orders of June 16 and August 20, 2026, which had stayed the earlier and the latest notifications.
How the dispute unfolded
The Authority was first constituted by a notification dated March 28, 2025. A quo warranto petition followed, as the same officer was serving as Transport Secretary and Managing Director of MPRTC. That notification was withdrawn and replaced on February 9, 2026.
The petitioners challenged the new notification, arguing that a Secretary can be appointed under Section 63, not Section 68(1). On June 16, 2026, the court stayed it after the State itself said the notification had irregularities. A fresh notification followed on August 10, 2026, was challenged by amendment, and was stayed on August 20.
The petitioners argued that Section 68(1) has no provision for nominating members, so the State should have appointed named persons as Chairman and member. Asked to explain whether such a notification must name the person rather than the post, counsel “could not elaborate his arguments on that issue”, the bench noted.
The court found the argument untenable. Section 68(1), it said, “merely provides” that the State shall constitute the Authority, and “it cannot be said that every time a notification designating an individual to act as Chairman or member is to be issued.” The notification only means that if a Chairman leaves office, the State need not issue a new one, since another officer of the same rank can be nominated.
Rejecting the claim of unchecked power, the bench said: “Appointment of any individual as Chairman and nomination of any individual as Chairman by the State Government are one and the same thing.” The only limit, it held, is Section 68(2), which requires judicial or adjudicating experience. Officers of this rank, the court observed, are IAS officers who have exercised quasi-judicial powers as SDM, Collector, Additional Commissioner and Commissioner, and the petitioners never argued otherwise.
The bench also noted that nothing requires the Chairman to come from the Transport Department alone, and that the State’s source of power to constitute the Authority was not under challenge.
Intervener’s objections rejected
Intervener’s counsel Biswajit Das argued that invoking Section 68(2), which deals with qualifications, made the notification vulnerable, and that the Authority’s powers across the State were uncontrolled. The court disagreed, holding that the question of qualifications “would arise only when a person is nominated”. It added that a court “should presume the constitutionality of the notification and should not try to find out loopholes”. The second contention was termed “misconceived”, as nobody had challenged the validity of Section 68(1) itself.
Concluding that the notification dated August 10, 2026 is “intra vires and is in accordance with law”, the court upheld it, dismissed the petition and left the State at liberty to proceed in accordance with law.
According to the ruling, the Authority can now resume issuing and renewing permits, including inter-state bus permits, and the decision is expected to speed up the planned 280 inter-regional bus routes under the Mukhyamantri Sugam Parivahan Seva.
Senior Advocate M.P.S. Raghuvanshi with Advocate Himanshu Sharma appeared for the petitioners. Additional Advocate General Vivek Khedkar with Government Advocate Sohit Mishra represented the State. Senior Advocate Arvind Dudawat with Advocate Abhishek Singh Kaurav, and Advocates Sourav Singh Tomar, Biswajit Das, Neerendra Sharma and Geetesh Marwah appeared for the interveners, while Advocates Prashant Sharma and Shailendra Gupta appeared for respondent No. 7.
Case Title: Harishankar Singh Patel and Others vs. The State of Madhya Pradesh and Others
Order Date: October 14, 2026
Bench: Justice G.S. Ahluwalia and Justice Anuradha Shukla
