‘Police Machinery Moved Only Under Court’s Gaze’: Allahabad HC Slams UP Police Over 10-Year Delay In FIR

Allahabad High Court penalises state over decade-long police inaction.
The Allahabad High Court recently criticised the Uttar Pradesh Police for failing to pursue an FIR for more than 10 years, observing that the entire police machinery moved into action only after the complainant approached the court, describing the conduct as gross dereliction of duty.
"A perusal of the record reflects an alarming state of affairs...For more than a decade, the said F.I.R. was never taken to its logical conclusion...It is therefore apparent that the entire machinery went into motion only under the compelling gaze of this Court," observed the bench of Justice Abdul Moin and Justice Pramod Kumar Srivastava.
Court directed the Uttar Pradesh government to pay ₹25,000 as exemplary costs to the petitioner.
"A litigant who knocks on the doors of the justice delivery system cannot be made to suffer indefinitely on account of bureaucratic lethargy and sheer indifference of the police authorities," said the bench.
The bench was dealing with a writ petition filed by one Chandbabu, who had approached the high court alleging that the police had failed to complete the investigation and file a charge sheet in an FIR registered in 2015 at Mandhata Police Station in Pratapgarh district.
The FIR, registered on March 28, 2015, invoked Sections 147, 148, 149, 323, 452, 504 and 506 of the Indian Penal Code. It was lodged against certain named and unnamed persons.
The petitioner contended that despite the passage of more than a decade, the investigating authorities had neither concluded the investigation nor submitted a police report before the competent court. He subsequently submitted a representation to the Superintendent of Police, Pratapgarh, on September 11, 2026, seeking action.
During the initial hearing on September 28, the State informed the court that the charge sheet had first been forwarded on April 24, 2015, but certain objections were raised. Following further investigation, it was forwarded again on June 10, 2023. However, the case diary was subsequently misplaced, preventing its filing before the court.
Taking note of the explanation, the high court expressed surprise that the police report had not been filed despite the FIR dating back to 2015. It also observed that the Station House Officer concerned had not taken any action and directed the Superintendent of Police, Pratapgarh, to personally conduct an inquiry and submit an affidavit along with the inquiry report.
On October 14, the court was informed that the missing charge sheet had been traced and filed before the competent court on October 6. The Superintendent of Police also informed the bench that an inquiry had been initiated against Head Constable Vishnu Kant Singh for dereliction of duty and that a show-cause notice had been issued to him on October 9.
Court subsequently sought an explanation from the Superintendent of Police as to why exemplary costs should not be imposed, considering that the complainant had been waiting for justice for nearly a decade.
In his personal affidavit, the Superintendent of Police tendered an unconditional apology, attributing the delay to the case diary and other papers having been misplaced by the staff. The State also informed the court that the competent court had taken cognizance of the matter on October 14, 2026.
Rejecting the explanation as inadequate, the bench observed that the manner in which the matter had been handled indicated "gross dereliction of duty".
"Senior police officials are expected to actively supervise investigations and monitor criminal proceedings pending within their jurisdiction rather than waking up only when notices and orders are issued by this Court," the bench said.
Court further remarked that the show-cause notice had been met with a casual explanation, despite the serious lapse in the handling of the case.
Holding that the petitioner was entitled to compensation for the delay of more than 10 years in the performance of statutory duties by the authorities, the high court imposed exemplary token costs of Rs 25,000.
It directed the Uttar Pradesh government to pay the amount to the petitioner within four weeks from the date of receipt of a certified copy of the order. Court, however, left it open to the State Government to recover the amount from police officials found responsible for the delay and dereliction of duty.
With these directions, court disposed of the writ petition.
Case Title: Chandbabu v. State of U.P. Through Principal Secretary, Revenue, Lucknow & 2 Others
Bench: Justice Abdul Moin and Justice Pramod Kumar Srivastava
Order Date: November 16, 2026
