'Tipping Is Customer's Discretion', Remarks Delhi HC Admitting Restaurant Associations' Appeals Over Mandatory Service Charge Ban

Tipping Is Customers Discretion, Remarks Delhi HC Admitting Restaurant Associations Appeals Over Mandatory Service Charge Ban
X
The Division Bench orally questioned the restaurant industry's justification for separately collecting service charges, observing that customers cannot be compelled to pay tips in India.

The Delhi High Court today admitted appeals filed by restaurant associations challenging a March 2025 Single Judge's judgment upholding the Central Consumer Protection Authority's (CCPA) guidelines prohibiting hotels and restaurants from automatically adding service charges to customers' bills.

During the hearing, the Division Bench questioned the restaurant industry's argument that service charge was a long-standing practice and that the amount was collected for the welfare of staff. The Bench observed that payment of a tip was entirely at the customer's discretion.

"No, no, no, that is completely discretion of the customer" the Bench orally remarked when counsel referred to the earlier practice of customers giving tips directly to waiters.

The Bench further observed that while certain foreign countries have rules requiring customers to pay a specified percentage as a tip, there is no such legislation in India.

"There is no legislation to that effect" the Bench observed.

The appeals challenge the March 28, 2025 judgment of a Single Judge, which upheld the CCPA's guidelines dated July 4, 2022, prohibiting restaurants and hotels from automatically levying service charges.

Restaurant industry argues guidelines are only advisory

Counsel appearing for the restaurant industry argued that the CCPA's guidelines were merely advisory and could not be enforced as law.

It was submitted that the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 provides for framing rules and regulations, which are required to be placed before both Houses of Parliament. The CCPA, however, had issued guidelines bypassing this statutory procedure and was now seeking to enforce them as binding legal provisions.

Counsel further argued that the authority had effectively enlarged the definition of "unfair trade practice" under the Act by treating non-compliance with the guidelines as such a practice.

Defending the separate collection of service charge, counsel submitted that it was an age-old practice in the restaurant industry and that the amount was utilised for the welfare of staff. Fine-dining restaurants, counsel added, offered customised services apart from preparing food according to customers' preferences.

The counsel argued that restaurants were entitled to decide how they priced their products and services, and that separately identifying the service charge was intended to ensure transparency.

"It is only for the purpose of transparency that it is not included [in the food bill]" counsel submitted.

The Bench questioned the restaurant industry's insistence on separately levying a service charge.

"See you bring suppose you bring certain items for 100 rupees. You process it. You sell it for 1000 rupees. Do they come and question you? That this 900 is a hidden charge? No. It's your processing fees" the Bench remarked.

The Bench also referred to expenses incurred towards running a kitchen, employees, electricity, maintenance and hygiene, observing that these costs also included providing services to customers.

Counsel responded that a separately disclosed service charge was not a hidden charge since customers were informed about it in advance through the menu card.

Centre says restaurants continue practice despite judgment

Opposing the appeals, Additional Solicitor General Chetan Sharma submitted that the Single Judge had delivered a reasoned judgment holding that restaurants could not arrogate to themselves the power of the State to impose such a levy.

The CCPA argued that restaurants were free to determine the prices of food items but could not separately compel customers to pay an additional amount in the name of service charge.

Counsel further submitted that the authority had received thousands of complaints from across the country and that, despite the Single Judge's judgment, some restaurants continued the same practice.

The Bench observed that it was for the authority to take action against establishments violating the guidelines.

"Ball is in your court. It is for you to take action. We can't take action" the Bench remarked.

When the issue of interim relief was raised, the Bench clarified that no interim relief had been granted.

What the Single Judge held?

The petitions were filed by the National Restaurant Association of India and the Federation of Hotel and Restaurant Associations of India challenging the CCPA's July 4, 2022 guidelines.

The guidelines prohibit hotels and restaurants from automatically adding service charges to bills, collecting them under another name, forcing customers to pay them, or restricting entry or services because a customer refuses to pay.

They also prohibit adding service charge to the bill and levying GST on that amount.

Dismissing the petitions on March 28, 2025, the Single Judge held that the CCPA had statutory authority to issue the guidelines under Section 18(2)(l) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019.

The Court rejected the contention that the guidelines were merely advisory and held that they were mandatory under the statutory scheme of the Act.

The Court also rejected the argument that the guidelines violated restaurants' right to carry on business under Article 19(1)(g) of the Constitution, holding that the restrictions were in the larger interest of consumers.

It clarified that restaurants remained free to determine the prices of their food and services, but could not impose an additional mandatory service charge over and above the displayed price and applicable taxes.

The Single Judge further rejected the argument that displaying a service charge on the menu card created a binding contract with customers.

It held that a condition requiring mandatory payment of service charge would constitute an unfair contract under Section 2(46) of the Act and would not be enforceable.

The Court held that service charge or tip was a voluntary payment by the customer and could not be made compulsory. The petitions were dismissed with costs of ₹1 lakh each, to be deposited with the CCPA for consumer welfare.

The Division Bench has now admitted the appeals but has not granted interim relief.

Case title - NATIONAL RESTAURANT ASSOCIATION OF INDIA v UNION OF INDIA & ANR.

Next Story