7 Years' Combined Experience As Advocate, Judicial Officer Qualifies One For District Judge Post: SC

Supreme Court clarifies that seven years of combined experience as an advocate and judicial officer qualifies candidates for district judge appointments under Article 233.
X

Supreme Court clarifies eligibility criteria for district judge appointments.

Supreme Court reiterates that judicial officers can combine their experience at the Bar and in judicial service to meet the seven-year eligibility requirement under Article 233 of the Constitution.

The Supreme Court has clarified that a person seeking appointment as a district judge under Article 233 of the Constitution can meet the eligibility requirement of seven years' experience through a combination of practice as an advocate and service as a judicial officer.

A Bench of Justices M M Sundresh and Prasanna B Varale held that a person who has been or is in judicial service and has a combined experience of seven years or more as an advocate and a judicial officer is eligible for consideration and appointment as a district judge or additional district judge.

Court made the observation while allowing a plea filed by Rahul Singh, a judicial officer who was denied appointment as an additional district judge on the ground that he did not have seven years of continuous practice at the Bar.

Judicial officer denied appointment despite clearing the selection process

Singh had approached the Supreme Court under Article 32 of the Constitution seeking a direction to the Madhya Pradesh High Court to appoint him as an additional district and sessions judge in accordance with his selection in the Madhya Pradesh Higher Judicial Services (Entry Level) Examination, 2017, conducted through direct recruitment from the Bar.

He had also challenged the decisions dated January 31, 2018 and May 21, 2018, through which his candidature was rejected on the ground that he did not have seven years of continuous practice as an advocate as of April 13, 2017, the last date for submitting applications.

Court noted that Singh had approximately 10 years and one month of experience as an advocate and another one year and three months of experience as a judicial officer. He had also cleared all three stages of the Madhya Pradesh Higher Judicial Services selection process.

Despite this, the Madhya Pradesh High Court did not issue him an appointment letter because he did not fulfil the requirement of seven years of continuous practice at the Bar.

The question before the Court, therefore, was whether the seven-year experience requirement under Article 233 could be calculated by including the period spent in judicial service.

What did the Constitution Bench hold on seven years' combined experience?

The Bench observed that the issue was no longer res integra (an unsettled question of law).

It referred to the Constitution Bench judgment in Rejanish K.V. v. K. Deepa (2026), which clarified that the period of service rendered as a judicial officer must also be included while calculating the required seven years of experience.

In that judgment, the Constitution Bench had held that judicial officers who had completed seven years of practice at the Bar before joining the subordinate judicial service would be eligible for appointment as district judges or additional district judges through direct recruitment.

It had further clarified that eligibility for appointment must be determined as on the date of application.

The Constitution Bench had also observed that although Article 233(2) does not prescribe any eligibility requirement for a person already in the judicial service of the Union or a State to be appointed as a district judge, a level playing field must be maintained between advocates and in-service candidates.

Accordingly, it directed that candidates applying as in-service judicial officers must have seven years of combined experience as an advocate and a judicial officer.

"A person who has been or who is in judicial service and has a combined experience of seven years or more as an advocate or a judicial officer would be eligible for being considered and appointed as a District Judge/Additional District Judge under Article 233 of the Constitution," the Constitution Bench had held.

It had also prescribed 35 years as the minimum age for consideration and appointment as a district judge or additional district judge for both advocates and judicial officers, as on the date of application.

Further, the Constitution Bench had clarified that the contrary view taken in earlier judgments, beginning with Satya Narain Singh v. High Court of Allahabad (1985) and continuing until Dheeraj Mor v. High Court of Delhi (2020), did not lay down the correct proposition of law.

In the present case, the Bench noted that Singh had been functioning as an additional district and sessions judge since April 2019, pursuant to an interim order passed by the Supreme Court on April 22, 2019.

Court also took note of the fact that his selection was based on merit.

"It is not in dispute that the writ petitioner has been selected on merits. In such view of the matter, the interim order passed by this Court is made absolute, and the writ petition stands allowed by directing the respondent(s) to continue the service of the writ petitioner," the Bench held.

Court further directed that Singh be granted all benefits, including seniority and other service benefits, to which he would have been entitled pursuant to his original selection.

Case Title: Rahul Singh Vs Hon'ble High Court of Madhya Pradesh & Anr

Bench: Justices M M Sundresh and Prasanna B Varale

Date of Judgment: October 13, 2026

Click here to download judgment

Tags

Next Story