Foreign Divorce Decree Cannot Shield Husband From Bigamy Case: Supreme Court

Supreme Court rules on recognition of foreign divorce decrees and bigamy prosecution under Indian matrimonial law.
X

Foreign divorce decree cannot shield husband from bigamy prosecution.

Supreme Court holds that a foreign divorce on grounds not recognised under Hindu law cannot dissolve an Indian marriage, permitting bigamy prosecution under Section 494 IPC and Section 82 BNS.

The Supreme Court has held that a foreign matrimonial decree cannot automatically be recognised in India if it is passed on a ground that is not recognised under Indian matrimonial law, observing that a husband cannot rely on such a decree to escape prosecution for bigamy.

A Bench of Justices Prashant Kumar Mishra and Shree Chandrashekhar dismissed a plea filed by a medical practitioner who, after obtaining a divorce decree from a British court and acquiring British citizenship through naturalisation, contracted a second marriage. He had challenged the registration of an FIR against him for bigamy under Section 494 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (Section 82 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023).

Court noted that the British court had made the divorce decree final on January 29, 2014, on the ground of irretrievable breakdown of marriage. However, this ground is not statutorily recognised under the Hindu matrimonial laws governing the marriage between the husband and his first wife.

"Such a decree cannot automatically be accorded recognition in India. In our view, the foreign divorce decree was passed in contravention of the existing matrimonial law in India and on a ground that is not even recognized statutorily," the Bench said.

Why was the foreign divorce decree not recognised in India?

Court observed that the decree failed to satisfy the requirements of Section 13 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (CPC), which governs the recognition of foreign judgments in India. It also referred to the principles laid down in Y. Narasimha Rao and Others v. Y. Venkata Lakshmi and Another (1991).

The Bench said that if a foreign decree does not satisfy Section 13 of the CPC, a husband cannot rely on it to claim that his first marriage stood dissolved under Indian matrimonial law and thereby escape prosecution under Section 494 of the IPC (Section 82 of the BNS).

"If the foreign decree does not satisfy the requirements of Section 13 of the CPC, whether the husband while relying on such a decree contend that his first marriage stood dissolved in the eyes of matrimonial laws of India and, thus, escape the rigours of Section 494 of the IPC, in our view, this cannot be permitted," the Bench said.

Referring to Sections 13 and 14 of the CPC, the Bench explained that these provisions are largely an extension of the principle of res judicata. A judgment delivered by a foreign court of competent jurisdiction can be recognised and enforced by an Indian court, and operate as res judicata between the parties, provided it satisfies the conditions prescribed under Section 13.

"The larger policy behind these provisions is to further the principle of comity of nations subject to the general principles of justice, equity and good conscience," the Bench said.

Court further explained that Section 14 of the CPC raises a presumption regarding the competence of the foreign court that delivered the judgment. Once a foreign judgment satisfies the requirements of Section 13 and other applicable conditions, including the principles of natural justice, equity and good conscience, the executing court cannot reopen its validity or legality.

The Bench said similar principles apply to private international law, particularly the recognition of foreign matrimonial decrees. Such decrees must be tested against Section 13 of the CPC, the law governing the marriage and the jurisdictional principles recognised by the concerned country.

Court also referred to Satya Singh v. Teja Singh (1975), which held that no country is bound by the principle of comity to give effect to the divorce laws of another country if they are repugnant to its own laws and public policy.

In the present case, the Bench noted that the husband had initially approached a court in Guntur seeking dissolution of his first marriage. After failing to obtain the relief, he preferred an appeal before the high court but subsequently withdrew it.

"Instead of contesting his appeal here in India, he chose to file for divorce proceedings before a foreign court after allegedly obtaining the citizenship of United Kingdom in the interregnum. The foreign court thereafter made the decree of divorce final in 2014, on the ground of irretrievable breakdown marriage; a ground not statutorily recognized under the Hindu Laws," the Bench said.

Court also rejected the husband's argument that the first wife had participated in the proceedings before the British court and was therefore bound by its decree. It noted that her participation did not amount to unconditional submission to the foreign court's jurisdiction, as she had raised objections to it.

Can British citizenship and a second marriage abroad shield the husband from bigamy prosecution?

The Bench rejected the husband's contention that since he was a British citizen when the second marriage was solemnised, and the marriage took place outside India, he could not be prosecuted under Indian law in view of Section 4 of the IPC [Section 1(5) of the BNS, which provides for the application of the Sanhita to specified extra-territorial offences].

Court observed that the husband had contracted his first marriage in India under Hindu rites, rituals and customs. Therefore, the fact that the second marriage took place outside India did not dilute the allegations of bigamy.

"We cannot accept this submission in the manner canvassed as the husband was married to the first wife in India under the Hindu rites, rituals and customs, thus, even if the second marriage took place outside India, the allegations under Section 494 of the IPC cannot be said to be diluted since enquiry for the offence of bigamy cannot be confined to the place of second marriage but must necessarily take into account the subsisting matrimonial relationship," the Bench said.

Court further stressed that the legal consequences arising from a subsisting marriage cannot be defeated by a subsequent change in the husband's nationality.

Bigamy is a continuing offence

Rejecting the argument that the FIR was lodged with an unexplained delay of around two years, the Bench observed that the issue could not be examined at this stage as bigamy is a continuing offence.

"Thus, on every occasion the disobedience or noncompliance occurs, the offence is committed," the Bench said.

The appellants had pointed out that the British court's divorce proceedings culminated in a final decree on January 29, 2014, and the second marriage took place on March 3, 2014. However, the first wife lodged the complaint only on February 1, 2016. They alleged that the complaint was filed to harass the husband.

Background

The husband, his second wife and his parents had approached the Supreme Court challenging the Andhra Pradesh High Court's July 8, 2019 judgment. The high court had dismissed their petition under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (Section 528 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023), seeking quashing of the criminal proceedings pending before the Additional Junior Civil Judge, Sattenapalli, Guntur district.

The appellants argued that the IPC could not apply to acts committed abroad by foreign citizens. They maintained that the divorce decree passed by the Cambridge County Court was valid and that the first marriage was no longer subsisting when the second marriage was solemnised.

They also contended that the decree, unless set aside by a competent civil court in India, was presumed to be valid under Section 14 of the CPC.

Court examined whether the foreign divorce decree, passed on the ground of irretrievable breakdown of marriage, was entitled to recognition in India under Section 13 of the CPC and, if not, whether the husband could rely on it to escape prosecution under Section 494 of the IPC. It also considered whether the high court was justified in refusing to exercise its inherent jurisdiction under Section 482 of the CrPC against the appellants.

While sustaining the criminal proceedings against the husband, the Supreme Court quashed them against his parents and second wife, finding no overt act attributable to them in the commission of the alleged offence.

Case Title: N Sridhar Reddy Vs The State of AP Through Secretary & Ors

Bench: Justices Prashant Kumar Mishra and Shree Chandrashekhar

Date of Judgment: November 03, 2026

Click here to download judgment

Tags

Next Story