Mere Allegation Of Illicit Relationship Cannot Prove Motive For Murder: Supreme Court Acquits Man

Supreme Court sets aside murder conviction over unproven motive and gaps in circumstantial evidence.
X

The Supreme Court found prosecution failed to establish murder motive.

The Supreme Court held that an alleged illicit relationship, unproven motive, unexplained delay in recording witness statements and doubtful recoveries could not establish guilt beyond reasonable doubt in a murder case based on circumstantial evidence.

The Supreme Court has held that a mere allegation of an illicit relationship between an accused and the deceased, without evidence that the accused acted on a specific suspicion or motive, is based on conjecture and cannot sustain a murder conviction.

A Bench of Justices Prashant Kumar Mishra and Vipul M Pancholi emphasised that in cases based entirely on circumstantial evidence, motive assumes considerable importance as a crucial link in the chain of circumstances.

Setting aside the murder conviction of one Bheemanagouda alias Bheemajja, Court observed that although motive is a vital link in circumstantial evidence cases, the prosecution failed to establish that the appellant suspected the deceased of having an illicit relationship with another person.

The appeal challenged the Karnataka High Court's July 9, 2024 judgment dismissing the appellant's criminal appeal and upholding his conviction and life sentence awarded by the II Additional District and Sessions Judge and Special Judge, Davanagere, on April 27 and 28, 2017, respectively.

The case arose from an FIR registered on September 5, 2013, after a woman's body was found inside an iron drum at a limestone kiln. Two days later, her family members identified her as Sharadamma, wife of Hanumanthappa.

According to the prosecution, the appellant was in an illicit relationship with the deceased, who had been living separately from her husband for over a decade. The prosecution further alleged that the appellant suspected her of being involved in an illicit relationship with another man.

It was alleged that around midnight on September 4, 2013, the appellant took the deceased to a limestone furnace near Hirekere, Harapanahalli, strangled her with a plastic strap, robbed her ornaments and placed her body inside an iron drum to conceal the crime.

Examining the evidence, Court found that both the trial court and the high court erred in treating general knowledge of an alleged illicit relationship as proof of the motive to commit murder.

On examining the depositions of the deceased's family members, including her nephew, husband, son and cousin, Court found that although the deceased was living separately from her husband and there were allegations of an illicit relationship with the appellant, none of the witnesses testified that the appellant suspected her of being involved with another man or that the two had quarrelled over the issue.

"Significantly, none of the prosecution witnesses testified that the appellant harboured suspicion that the deceased was involved with another man or that any quarrel had ever taken place between them on that account. Thus, we are of the opinion that the motive alleged by the prosecution is a matter of conjecture and surmise, which cannot be accepted as an established circumstance against the appellant," the Bench observed.

Court also rejected the prosecution's reliance on the 'last seen together' circumstance. It noted that the high court relied on the testimonies of witnesses without addressing the 58-day delay in recording their statements or giving any reason for reversing the trial court's finding on the unexplained delay.

"Thus, we are of the view that where the delay in recording the statements remains completely unexplained, the 'last seen' evidence is not conclusively established and was rightly rejected by the trial court," the Bench said.

Court also questioned the prosecution's version regarding the discovery of the deceased's body.

It noted that around 9 AM on September 5, 2013, the complainant, who owned the limestone kiln, received a phone call informing him that a woman's body was lying inside a lime drum. He immediately reached the site, discovered the body with its limbs folded inside the drum and alerted the workers present there.

However, the investigating agency neither traced nor examined the person who had informed the complainant about the body.

Further, neither the inquest report nor the post-mortem report prepared by Dr Raju G M mentioned any trace or stain of limestone on the deceased's clothes or body.

"Thus, we are of the opinion that this circumstance as well creates doubt as to the veracity of the prosecution version regarding the discovery of the body," the Bench observed.

Court further noted that none of the prosecution witnesses, including the investigating officer, stated that the appellant had placed the deceased's body inside a barrel with the intention of causing the disappearance of evidence.

Significantly, the State had not challenged the appellant's acquittal under Section 201 IPC (Section 238 BNS), which had consequently attained finality.

Regarding the recovery of some of the deceased's ornaments at the instance of the appellant, Court held that the prosecution had failed to establish that she was wearing those ornaments when she was last seen alive with him.

The Bench also accepted the appellant's submission that, given the alleged intimate relationship between the two, it was plausible that some of the deceased's belongings, including ornaments, might have been kept or left at his house in the ordinary course of their association.

"It is also pertinent to note that the sole motive advanced by the prosecution and accepted by the courts below was that the appellant committed murder of the deceased on account of an illicit relationship between them coupled with suspicion regarding her character. Thus, where the motive of the offence is rooted in personal animosity arising out of such a relationship, the prosecution did not establish any motive or intent for the appellant to commit theft of her jewellery," the Bench said.

Court also pointed out that no charge had been framed against the appellant under Sections 379, 392 or 404 IPC (Sections 303(2), 309(4) and 315 BNS) for theft, robbery or dishonest misappropriation of property.

The prosecution had tried him exclusively for offences punishable under Sections 302 and 201 IPC (Sections 103(1) and 238 BNS).

It therefore held that the recovery of ornaments, by itself, could not be used to infer the appellant's guilt for murder under Section 302 IPC (Section 103(1) BNS).

On an overall assessment of the evidence, the Bench held that the chain of circumstantial evidence was neither complete nor unbroken.

It found that the prosecution had failed to establish circumstances pointing conclusively towards the appellant's guilt beyond reasonable doubt.

"The findings of guilt recorded by the trial court and confirmed by the high court are based on conjectures and surmises. Therefore, the appellant is entitled to the benefit of doubt and the conviction under Section 302 IPC cannot be sustained in law," the Bench observed.

Accordingly, Court allowed the appeal and set aside the judgments of the high court and the trial court.

Since the appellant was in custody serving his life sentence, Court directed that he be released forthwith, unless his presence was required in connection with any other case.

Case Title: Bheemanagouda alias Bheemajja Vs State by Harapanahalli Police

Bench: Justices Prashant Kumar Mishra and Vipul M Pancholi

Date of Judgment: November 18, 2026

Click here to download judgment

Tags

Next Story