Supreme Court Expunges Madras HC's Remarks Against IPS Officer A Arun, Accepts Unconditional Apology

Supreme Court expunges adverse Madras High Court remarks against Tamil Nadu IPS officer A Arun over a preventive detention order under the Goondas Act.
X

Supreme Court expunges remarks against Tamil Nadu IPS officer.

The Supreme Court accepted IPS officer A Arun's unconditional apology and expunged the Madras High Court's adverse remarks over a preventive detention order under the Tamil Nadu Goondas Act.

The Supreme Court has expunged adverse remarks made by the Madras High Court against senior Tamil Nadu cadre IPS officer A Arun for ordering the preventive detention of a real estate developer under the Tamil Nadu Goondas Act, after accepting his unconditional apology.

A Bench of Justices Vikram Nath, R Mahadevan and Aparesh Kumar Singh accepted the apology and assurance furnished by the officer but cautioned that an apology cannot substitute for due care while exercising powers affecting an individual's liberty.

The high court had, on May 29, 2026, set aside a detention order passed by Arun, then Commissioner of Police, Greater Chennai, against Santhosh Sharma, a real estate developer and director of Lokaa Developers Pvt Ltd, who faced allegations of property fraud and cheating.

The high court had observed that the officer was "habituated" to issuing reckless preventive detention orders that were repeatedly quashed by courts.

Arun, presently serving as Director of the Tamil Nadu Police Academy, approached the Supreme Court through senior advocate Sidharth Luthra, submitting that he had realised his mistake and was willing to tender an unconditional apology.

The counsel argued that allowing the adverse remarks to remain on record could have serious repercussions for the officer's professional reputation and career. The officer also filed an affidavit tendering an unconditional apology.

In the affidavit, Arun expressed regret for not apologising before the high court and for failing to acknowledge the error committed while passing the detention order on September 22, 2025.

He further stated that he ought to have accepted his mistake when summoned by the high court. Having failed to do so, he tendered an unconditional apology to both the Supreme Court and the high court.

He also assured the Court that he would exercise greater care while discharging his official functions in the future.

Taking note of the unconditional apology and the assurance furnished by the officer, the Bench emphasised that public authorities must exercise statutory powers after carefully considering the facts and applicable law.

"The exercise of power by a public authority must be guided by a careful appreciation of the facts and the applicable law. This assumes particular significance in matters of preventive detention, where the exercise of statutory power directly affects the liberty of an individual. Such power must, therefore, be exercised with utmost circumspection and in strict conformity with the requirements of law," the Court observed.

The Court further said that an officer holding a senior position in the police administration is expected to understand the significance of the duties entrusted to him and the responsibility accompanying the exercise of statutory powers.

"The appellant's expression of regret and his assurance to exercise greater care in the future are duly noted. We trust that the same shall be reflected in the discharge of his official functions hereafter. We also caution that the tendering of an apology cannot be regarded as a substitute for due care in the exercise of powers affecting the liberty of a person," the Bench said.

While accepting the apology and expunging the adverse remarks made by the high court, the Court clarified that its order was confined to the observations against the officer and would not affect the high court's decision setting aside the preventive detention order.

Case Title: A Arun Vs Varsha Sharma & Ors

Bench: Justices Vikram Nath, R Mahadevan and Aparesh Kumar Singh

Date of Judgment: November 02, 2026

Click here to download judgment

Tags

Next Story