Supreme Court Expunges Remarks Against Judicial Officer, Says High Courts Must Hear Officers Before Criticising Them

Supreme Court stresses fairness in judicial officers' treatment.
The Supreme Court has held that a high court cannot condemn the conduct of a judicial officer on the judicial side without first giving the officer an opportunity to explain, observing that such remarks can damage the officer's career and have a chilling effect on the entire district judiciary.
A Bench of Justices Sandeep Mehta and Devendra Kumar Upadhyaya expunged adverse remarks and strictures recorded against a Rajasthan judicial officer by the high court, along with directions for her to undergo training in judgment writing and for the remarks to be included in her Annual Confidential Report (ACR).
Court observed that condemnation of a judicial officer's conduct by a high court on the judicial side would undeniably have adverse consequences for the officer's career. Such action, if taken without following the principles of natural justice, would be unsustainable in law.
Why had the high court criticised the judicial officer?
The high court's single judge bench had found that the judicial officer, while serving as a sessions judge, had used the cut-copy-paste method while writing two judgments in a POCSO case.
The high court had observed that the judge had "shirked her responsibility and neglected her duty" by not dictating the judgments in their entirety and had instead used the cut-copy-paste method, suggesting that they had effectively been written by the concerned stenographer or clerk.
It had further observed that the judge failed to read and correct the judgments after their preparation, resulting in irrelevant paragraphs remaining in the final versions.
The high court had directed that a copy of its order be sent to the judge in-charge of the Rajasthan Judicial Academy to impart training to the judicial officer on judgment writing. It had also directed the Registrar General to include the order in her ACR for 2024 after obtaining her comments.
What explanation did the judicial officer offer?
Before the Supreme Court, the judicial officer explained that the overlapping facts in the judgments arose because the two cases were intricately intermingled, with almost identical witnesses and substantive evidence.
She also pointed out that special courts under the POCSO Act had limited resources and were required to dispose of cases expeditiously within the statutory time frame.
The sole stenographer attached to her court had proceeded on leave, compelling her to dictate part of the judgment directly to the lower division clerk (LDC) on the computer. The remaining portion was dictated to the stenographer after he returned.
She further submitted that errors in the judgments, including incorrect serial numbers of prosecution witnesses, were bona fide typographical mistakes that neither altered nor affected the outcome or substance of the judgments.
Why did the Supreme Court expunge the remarks?
Considering her explanation, the Bench held that the adverse observations and strictures recorded by the high court were "uncalled for and avoidable".
Court noted that the remarks had been recorded on the judicial side without giving the judicial officer an opportunity to show cause or place her explanation on record, thereby violating the principles of natural justice.
"We are of the opinion that it was a fit case wherein the High Court, while exercising the power of superintendence, should have acted with greater magnanimity and in the true spirit of its role under Article 227 of the Constitution of India as guardian of the officers in the district judiciary," the Bench said.
It added that castigating a judicial officer for inadvertent typographical errors that did not affect the outcome of a case was avoidable.
"Such adverse remarks may have the deleterious effect of destroying the judicial officer's career and may also have a chilling effect on the entire district judiciary. In this background, we are unable to subscribe to the view taken by the High Court that the appellant-judicial officer was acting in dereliction of her duties while rendering the judgment dated 20th January, 2024," Court observed.
The Bench held that the course adopted by the high court was contrary to the fundamental principle of audi alteram partem, which requires that a person be given an opportunity to be heard before an adverse decision is taken against them.
It further observed that the case demonstrated how supervisory powers could have been exercised differently, with greater forgiveness and magnanimity.
In this regard, Court referred to English poet Alexander Pope's celebrated lines from An Essay on Criticism: "To err is human, to forgive, divine".
The Bench also referred to the Jain principle of "उत्तम क्षमा" (Uttama Kshama), as outlined in the Tattvartha Sutra, and the Sanskrit adage "क्षमा वीरस्य भूषणम्" (Kshama Virasya Bhushanam), which means forgiveness is the ornament of the brave.
Court said these principles reflected the virtue of forgiveness and that the present case was a fit illustration calling for its exercise.
The Bench directed the Registry to send a copy of its judgment to the Registrar General of the Rajasthan High Court for placing it before the Chief Justice.
Case Title: In Re: XXX, a Judicial Officer in the District Judge Cadre of Rajasthan Judicial Services
Bench: Justices Sandeep Mehta and Devendra Kumar Upadhyaya
Date of Judgment: November 02, 2026
