CJI Surya Kant Reassigns Two Matters From Justice Amanullah's Bench Over Turning Individual Disputes Into Nationwide PILs

CJI Surya Kant moves two of Justice Amanullah's widened cases to other benches, enforcing roster discipline
Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant has taken at least two matters away from a Supreme Court bench headed by Justice Ahsanuddin Amanullah. According to people aware of the matter, as reported by Hindustan Times, he did so after the bench, whose roster does not include public interest litigation, widened individual disputes into nationwide PILs.
The CJI is said to have acted after speaking with and apprising Justices Vikram Nath, BV Nagarathna, MM Sundresh and PS Narasimha.
The two matters concern a nationwide examination of regulatory failures in private universities and a separate exercise on unauthorised constructions and the misuse of residential properties across the country. Each began as an individual dispute before Justice Amanullah's bench and was later expanded to address wider systemic issues.
The reassignment is described as an unusual institutional step to enforce strict adherence to the roster. It reportedly follows a full court meeting held around four weeks ago, at which the CJI made clear that judges must decide matters strictly in accordance with the rosters assigned to them, and that orderly allocation of cases was essential to judicial discipline and public confidence in the administration of justice.
"The CJI was categorical in the full court meeting that the judges ought to work as per the roster to keep case allocation orderly, maintain judicial discipline and help preserve public confidence that justice is being administered fairly," a person aware of the matter told Hindustan Times.
The CJI's decision is said to send a message that no bench should step beyond its assigned roster, however compelling the cause may appear.
The first matter, Ayesha Jain v Amity University, Noida, arose from a student's grievance against the private university. She alleged harassment and the loss of an academic year after she legally changed her name.
The bench later expanded the proceedings into a nationwide examination of how private universities are established, funded and regulated, and issued directions to the Centre, the States and regulatory authorities.
The part-heard matter had been heard regularly by a bench of Justices Amanullah and NV Anjaria. It has now been assigned to a three-judge bench headed by Justice Vikram Nath, with Justices R Mahadevan and Aparesh Kumar Singh as members, and is listed for hearing on November 19.
The second matter, Loganathan v State of Tamil Nadu, was before a bench of Justices Amanullah and Mahadevan. It concerns unauthorised constructions and the commercial misuse of residential properties.
The proceedings began on March 25 this year, when the Court took note of an individual case from Chennai involving a one-and-a-half-storey building constructed without an approved plan. The bench then took up the issue on a pan-India scale and sought responses from States and from municipal authorities in major cities, including Delhi and the National Capital Region. Senior Advocate Ajit Kumar Sinha was appointed amicus curiae, assisted by Advocate Govind Jee.
The matter is now expected to come up before a bench headed by Justice BV Nagarathna on November 23.
A Bench without PIL jurisdiction must refer the matter to the CJI through the Registry
According to a second person aware of the matter, the correct course for a bench that considers a dispute to merit treatment as a PIL is a reference to the CJI, not self-expansion.
"As per roster, justice Amanullah does not have PILs as a matter he could examine and therefore, if his bench felt the matter required adjudication as a PIL, it ought to have been referred to the CJI through the court registry for appropriate orders," the person said.
The issue is also said to have been discussed at the full court meeting in light of a line of Supreme Court judgments recognising the Chief Justice of India, and the Chief Justices of the High Courts, as the master of the roster, and the duty of individual judges to stay within the judicial business allotted to them.
The five-judge Constitution Bench ruling in the Campaign for Judicial Accountability and Reforms case (2017) reaffirmed that the CJI alone has the prerogative to constitute benches and allocate cases. It held that neither a two-judge nor a three-judge bench can allocate a matter to itself or dictate the composition of a bench, and that no judge can take up a matter unless it has been allocated by the CJI.
The same principle was stated in State of Rajasthan v Prakash Chand (1997), where the Supreme Court had held that the Chief Justice alone has the prerogative to constitute benches and allocate judicial business, and that other judges can discharge only the work assigned to them.
In Jasbir Singh v State of Punjab (2006), the Court had emphasised that judicial discipline requires a judge who believes a matter should be heard by a particular court or bench to seek appropriate orders from the Chief Justice, rather than assume jurisdiction or direct the registry contrary to the roster.
Source: Hindustan Times
