Gulshan Pahuja Contempt Case: Supreme Court To Decide Alleged Breach Of Its Order Before Hearing His Appeal

Gulshan Pahujas contempt appeal to wait until Supreme Court rules on alleged breach of its order.
X

Supreme Court to decide alleged breach of its order before taking up Gulshan Pahuja's contempt appeal

Justice Dipankar Datta said the Court would hear the allegation of breach and not Pahuja's past conduct, and warned that a finding of breach would carry consequences

The Supreme Court on Monday made it clear that it will first examine whether Gulshan Pahuja has breached an earlier order of the Court, and will take up his appeal against his conviction for criminal contempt only thereafter.

Pahuja was sentenced by the Delhi High Court to six months' simple imprisonment for allegations made against judges and the judicial system, a sentence the Supreme Court suspended in September.

"If we find that there has been a breach, we will have to bear the consequences," Justice Dipankar Datta remarked towards the close of the hearing.

The audio and video of the proceedings remained switched off for most of the hearing.

Towards the conclusion of the hearing, Justice Datta set out the order in which the Court would proceed. The question of breach would be taken up first, and the appeal would follow, "Please tell him, we will hear him on the allegations that there has been a breach of our order, not the past conduct. First, we will hear whether there has been a breach of our order. Thereafter, we will consider his appeal. If we find that there has been a breach, we will have to bear the consequences."

The effect is that the challenge to the High Court's judgment will not be heard on merits until the Court has decided whether its own directions have been complied with.

Justice Datta drew a line around the scope of the inquiry. The Court, he said, would hear Pahuja "on the allegations that there has been a breach of our order, not the past conduct."

The hearing on breach will therefore be limited to whether the earlier order has been violated. It will not reopen Pahuja's conduct in general.

The matter has been adjourned for further hearing to the week commencing from December 14.

Background

Pahuja is before Supreme Court against the Delhi High Court order from May sentencing him to six months’ simple imprisonment and imposing a fine of Rs. 2,000 after holding him guilty of criminal contempt for remarks made against the judiciary in videos uploaded on his YouTube channel, “Fight 4 Judicial Reforms.”

"Judicial officers, you bring them charge of corruption without any supporting material. You tarnish image of judicial officers, and you know how social media reacts. The entire career of the judicial officer is at stake," the bench observed today.

A Division Bench comprising Justice Navin Chawla and Justice Ravinder Dudeja of the Delhi High Court held that Pahuja had “scandalised the court and lowered the authority of the Court” through his statements and conduct.

“In the present case, as found in our judgment dated 21.04.2026, the contemnor, by his acts, has scandalized the court and lowered the authority of the Court. The contemnor shows no regret for the same. He also does not suggest any course correction. In fact, he maintains that what he did was with the intent of improving the judicial system”, the Court observed.

The Court noted that Pahuja showed “no regret” and continued making objectionable remarks even during the hearing on sentencing.

During oral submissions, Pahuja had stated before High Court, “adaalaton ki manmarzi badhti jaa rahi hai aur main koi nyay ki umeed nahi kar raha” and further remarked that “manmarzi ka dusra arth taanashahi hota hai.” According to the Bench, these remarks aggravated the contempt already established against him. “He, in fact, compounds his contempt by making further scandalous submissions before this Court and thus, evidently he is neither repentant nor deserves any mercy,” the judges observed.

The contempt proceedings arose from videos uploaded by Pahuja featuring interviews with advocates Shiv Narayan Sharma and Deepak Singh, in which derogatory allegations were allegedly made against judges and courts. The matter reached the High Court after three judicial officers referred the videos and accompanying banners for initiation of contempt proceedings. While the two advocates tendered unconditional apologies and stated that they were unaware their interviews would be uploaded online with objectionable thumbnails and captions, the Court accepted their explanations and discharged them from the contempt proceedings.

Pahuja, however, defended his actions throughout the case, claiming that the videos formed part of a campaign seeking judicial reforms and audio-video recording of court proceedings. In an earlier judgment dated April 21, the High Court had already held him guilty under Section 2(c) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971.

During arguments on sentencing, Pahuja also alleged procedural irregularities in the contempt proceedings. He argued that the relevant judicial records had not been summoned, the judicial officers named in the videos were not examined as witnesses, and he had been denied the opportunity to cross-examine them. Rejecting these submissions, the Bench observed that it could not “sit in review” of its earlier judgment and clarified that Pahuja remained free to challenge the verdict in accordance with law.

Explaining why a stringent punishment was necessary, the Court stated, “We also find that by not imposing adequate punishment on him, we may encourage him to repeat these acts in future and to embolden him in doing the same.” The Court directed that the sentences in both contempt matters would run concurrently. However, exercising powers under Section 19(3) of the Contempt of Courts Act, the High Court suspended the sentence for 60 days to enable Pahuja to approach the Supreme Court of India in appeal.

Case Title: Gulshan Pahuja v. High Court of Delhi

Benck: Justices Dipankar Datta and Sheel Nagu

Hearing Date: November 16, 2026

Tags

Next Story