"Listed On Ten Occasions": Counsel For Bilkis Bano Case Convicts Denies Suppression, Says Bail Was Granted After 18 Years In Custody

Lawyer for two Bilkis Bano case convicts calls the charge that she was kept unaware factually incorrect.
X

Convicts' counsel says the Bilkis Bano bail matter was listed ten times and nothing was suppressed

Counsel for two convicts in the Bilkis Bano case issued a statement denying that the Supreme Court bail had been obtained behind her back. The statement said the matter was listed ten times over more than a year, no caveat had been filed, and she was not a party before the High Court

The lawyer for two men convicted in the 2002 Bilkis Bano gang-rape and murder case has rejected allegations that the Supreme Court granted them bail without the survivor's knowledge. He said in a statement on November 21, 2026 that the matter had come up before the Court ten times over more than a year before bail was granted.

The statement was issued by Advocate-on-Record (AoR) Ayush Anand, counsel for Bipinchand Kanaiyalal Joshi alias Lala Doctor and Pradip Ramanlal Modhiya, the appellants in Criminal Appeal Nos. 5118–5119 of 2026. It responds to what it calls "certain statements issued on behalf of the prosecutrix, including statements attributed to a Senior Advocate, which are, according to the petitioners, factually incorrect and appear to sensationalise the Court proceedings and question the sanctity of the legal process."

"The matter had been listed on ten occasions before bail was granted and had taken more than a year. In these circumstances, the allegation of suppression by the legal team of the prosecutrix, according to the petitioners, is entirely misconceived," the statement reads.

The statement begins by accepting that a press statement in a pending matter is out of the ordinary. "Ideally, an advocate should refrain from issuing press statements in a sub-judice matter," it says.

It explains that the statement was issued because "similar press statements by various groups have also contributed to a narrative that risks turning the pending criminal appeals before the Hon'ble Supreme Court into a subject of media trial."

On the role of the two men, the statement says that "there are different sets of accused in the case. The petitioners were not the main accused and were alleged to have been part of a mob. They were not initially named in relation to any specific overt act."

It also says that, "as per the petitioners' position, the prosecutrix in her statements dated 07.03.2002 and 13.03.2002 had not named the petitioners in the allegations of rape. A similar position was reflected in her statement before the doctor at the time of medical examination."

These are the petitioners' contentions in their pending appeals. Both men stand convicted. The trial court convicted them and the Bombay High Court confirmed the conviction and life sentence on May 4, 2017.

The statement sets out a detailed chronology. The petitioners filed their Special Leave Petition on August 15, 2025 (Diary No. 45823/2025). It was listed on September 16, October 15, November 10 and December 1, 2025, "during which all material facts and documents were placed before the Hon'ble Court."

A Bench issued notice on March 17, 2026. According to the statement, the fact that Petitioner No. 1 "was physically disabled and that both petitioners had remained behind bars for approximately 17 years was also noted while issuing notice in March 2026."

After notice, the matter was listed before another Bench on May 5, May 12, August 11 and September 22, 2026.

On October 12, 2026, a Criminal Miscellaneous Petition was filed seeking bail on medical grounds. The statement says that he "had suffered major cardiac blockages and undergone cardiac surgery while in custody, after approximately 18 years of incarceration." It describes "four cardiac blockages of approximately 80–90%", a coronary angiography on August 31, 2026 and, "following the detection of significant blockages on 08.09.2026, coronary artery bypass grafting."

A new Bench was constituted "due to procedural reasons" and the matter was listed on October 14, 2026, when the Court directed that the CBI Standing Counsel be served. Then, the statement says, "on 28.10.2026, following detailed hearing from both sides and considering that the petitioners' case would be heard in due course, bail was granted after approximately 18 years of incarceration during the pendency of the criminal appeals."

No caveat filed and survivor not a party before High Court

The statement's main legal answer to the "not heard" grievance is procedural. "There was no caveat filed on behalf of the prosecutrix in the matter. She was also not a party before the Hon'ble High Court, as reflected in the cause title. Accordingly, she was not impleaded in the proceedings," it says.

It adds: "The legal team representing the prosecutrix could have exercised the available procedural remedies, including seeking impleadment, and the absence of such action cannot be attributed to the petitioners or the Court."

The statement also says the survivor's side knew of the case. It claims that "the erstwhile legal team of the prosecutrix, at the time of challenging remission before the Hon'ble Supreme Court, was aware of the matter and, to our knowledge, was observing the Court proceedings."

It notes that the issue of notice on March 17, 2026 "was also reported by a major media outlet. Therefore, the allegation that the prosecutrix was unaware of the proceedings is, according to the petitioners, factually incorrect." The statement does not name the outlet.

"The legal team of the prosecutrix did not initiate any proceedings at that stage, despite the matter being pending and notice having been issued, and raised the issue subsequently," it says.

To show that the order was not unusual, the statement cites two other bail orders passed by the Supreme Court in criminal appeals. In Madhav Ram v. Patanjali Bhardwaj & Anr. (Criminal Appeal No. 1554/2022), it says, "bail was granted after 12 years of incarceration, considering serious health issues, on 07.10.2026." In Arun Gulab Gawali v. State of Maharashtra & Anr., "bail was granted after 18 years of incarceration on 28.08.2025."

The statement questions the timing of the criticism. "It is therefore unfortunate that, 18 days after the grant of bail, from 16.11.2026 onwards, the matter has suddenly been portrayed in a manner suggesting that the prosecutrix was unaware of the proceedings," it says.

It closes: "Publicity surrounding a pending matter should not come at the cost of factual accuracy, fairness or respect for the judicial process. It is expected that all concerned, including members of the legal fraternity, will exercise restraint and ensure that the proceedings are presented in their proper context."

Bilkis Bano said she would challenge the order

The statement responds to a statement issued by Bilkis Bano on November 16, 2026, through Senior Advocate Shobha Gupta. In it, she said the Court had suspended the sentences "without calling me up and without hearing me. I learnt of this through press reports," and that "I will fight this order. I must."

A Bench of Justices M M Sundresh and Prasanna B Varale suspended the two men's sentences on October 28, 2026. It recorded that "the appellants have been under incarceration for a period of more than seventeen years, and also the fact remains that one of the appellants has a severe handicap," and that "there are issues to be decided in the appeal, both on fact and law." The appeal is to be listed in due course.

In 2024, the Supreme Court set aside the premature release of all 11 convicts, which the Gujarat government had granted in August 2022.

Background

The order she refers to was passed in the appeals of Bipinchand Kanaiyalal Joshi alias Lala Doctor and Pradeep Ramanlal Modhiya. Both were convicted by the trial court under Sections 143, 147, 302 read with 149, 376(2)(e) and 376(2)(g) of the Indian Penal Code and sentenced to rigorous imprisonment for life with fine. The Bombay High Court confirmed the conviction and sentence on May 4, 2017.

Before the Supreme Court, Senior Advocates Sidharth Luthra and Sonia Mathura, for the appellants, argued that the convicts had spent over 17 years in prison, that one of them was not named in the FIR and was implicated nearly three years after the incident, and that one of them is severely handicapped. Additional Solicitor General (ASG) Raja Thakre, for the respondents, strongly opposed bail, contending that both courts below had carefully considered the record, and stressed the gravity of the offences.

The Bench held, "Having heard the parties, suffice it to state that the appellants have been under incarceration for a period of more than seventeen years, and also the fact remains that one of the appellants has a severe handicap. Certainly, there are issues to be decided in the appeal, both on fact and law. In view of the above and considering the issues involved in this appeal, we suspend the sentence and grant bail to the appellants on such terms and conditions as may be imposed by the concerned Trial Court."

The order comes after the Supreme Court in 2024 set aside the premature release of all 11 convicts that the Gujarat government had granted in August 2022.

Tags

Next Story