SCBA Contempt Case Over Posts On CJI Surya Kant: Supreme Court Seeks Additional Affidavits From Sanjay Raut And Nikhil Wagle

SCBA contempt case: Raut and Wagle to file additional affidavits and appear in person before the Supreme Court on December 8.
X

Supreme Court tells Sanjay Raut to show restraint in language, seeks fresh affidavits from him and Nikhil Wagle in SCBA contempt case

The Supreme Court told Sanjay Raut, a parliamentarian of 25 years, that he “should know what restraint in language means” and directed Raut and journalist Nikhil Wagle to file additional affidavits by December 8

The Supreme Court on Tuesday reminded Shiv Sena (UBT) MP Sanjay Raut that a parliamentarian of 25 years, who had also worked as a journalist, "should know what restraint in language means".

The Bench of Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M. Pancholi directed him and journalist Nikhil Wagle to file additional affidavits in the criminal contempt petition brought by the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) over social media posts concerning Chief Justice of India (CJI) Surya Kant.

Raut appeared in person and Wagle joined virtually, in compliance with the directions issued at the previous hearing on October 28. The matter will next be taken up on December 8 at 2 PM, when both respondents must remain physically present.


Senior Advocate Indira Jaising, appearing for Wagle (respondent No. 1), submitted that her client had complied with the Court's direction to remain present virtually. She pointed out that Wagle had filed an affidavit tendering a genuine, bona fide and unconditional apology for his social media post.

Jaising told the Bench that Wagle had deleted the post immediately, had apologised personally to the judge concerned as well as to the Supreme Court, and was present to offer any clarification the Bench might seek. On that basis, she urged the Court to discharge him from the contempt proceedings.

Opposing the plea, Senior Advocate Pradeep Rai, appearing for the SCBA, drew the Court's attention to Raut's social media conduct after the earlier posts.

Rai referred to posts in which Raut alleged that the BJP had brought India's democracy, judiciary, central investigating agencies and the Election Commission under its control. He cited another post stating that the judiciary, one of the four pillars of democracy, had fallen. He further pointed out that Raut had posted about an incident in Albania even after the contempt notice was issued.

Rai argued that this subsequent conduct had to be considered while examining Raut's apology, particularly since Raut is a Member of Parliament and a responsible public representative. He submitted that Raut's affidavit made no mention of the later posts, and described him as a "habitual offender".

"He is in a respected position. Some responsibility is expected from you. This has to be dealt with an iron hand," Rai submitted.

Rai also informed the Court that separate contempt proceedings against Raut are pending before the Bombay High Court.

He later drew the Bench's attention to another post dated October 11, which referred to the Leader of Opposition's planned visit to the Supreme Court and to CJI Surya Kant's direction concerning an ED-related meeting request. Flagging the language used in that post, Rai submitted that the Court should also examine Raut's choice of words, given his position as a public representative. He sought permission to place additional material concerning Raut on record.

Addressing Raut directly, the Bench said, "We have heard your debates many times, even during our days as advocates. You are a seasoned and experienced parliamentarian. You have been in Parliament for 25 years. You should know what restraint in language means. You yourself were in the press. You are also a journalist. You should know what restraint your words require."

The Court then asked Raut to explain his position on the remarks.

Jaising sought the Court's guidance on how Wagle should respond to the disputed language in his post. One possible approach, she submitted, would be to show that the word used had entered common parlance, for which several dictionaries and judgments could be cited.

She then offered the alternative, "The other approach is to say it is not at all dignified. It is not at all appropriate. It is not a word that serious journalists should use."

Jaising added that if there had been a slip on Wagle's part, she could only place his genuine apology before the Court, and offered to have him answer any questions the Bench wished to put to him. "I want guidance from the Court so that I can advise my client what to do," she said.

The Bench made it clear that Wagle should set out his response on affidavit rather than offer an oral clarification.

"Whatever he wants to say on this, whether by way of apology or otherwise, let him put it on his affidavit with reference to particularly these two tweets," the Court said.

Jaising clarified that, according to her, only one tweet was in question, and described the choice of words as a slip. "Sometimes, you know what happens between when you are sipping the tea. If there's a slip between the cup and the lip, it will slip out. It can hurt, it can harm, it can do anything," she said.

She also drew a distinction between using an abusive word against a judge and committing contempt of court in law, submitting that the legal question would have to be examined separately.

Justice Aravind Kumar indicated that the Court would consider Wagle's affidavit and the additional material concerning Raut, and pass a comprehensive order on the next date of hearing.

By its order, the Court directed both respondents to file additional affidavits in advance of the next hearing. It said it would consider their responses and explore the appropriate way forward. The matter is listed on December 8 at 2 PM, and both Raut and Wagle have been directed to remain physically present.

Background

The SCBA's petition arises from social media posts by Wagle and Raut concerning CJI Surya Kant. The Court issued contempt notice to both on October 16. At the hearing on October 28, Wagle tendered an unconditional apology, read out by Jaising, and the SCBA, then represented by Senior Advocate Rahul Kaushik, relied on a Delhi High Court order of June 19, 2026 dealing with a misinformation campaign against judges. The Bench, which then comprised Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M. Pancholi, directed Wagle to join the next hearing virtually and Raut, for whom no appearance had been entered, to be physically present.

Notably, on October 29, Sanjay Raut had also tendered an unconditional and unqualified apology to the Court.

Case Title: Supreme Court Bar Association v. Nikhil Wagle and Anr.

Bench: Justices Aravind Kumar and Vipul M. Pancholi

Hearing Date: November 17, 2026

Tags

Next Story