Supreme Court Dismisses Plea Against Animal Killing In The Name Of Religion

Supreme Court dismisses plea to stop brutal killing of animals in the name of religion
The Supreme Court on Wednesday dismissed a petition that sought directions to the Union Government to protect animals from brutal killing carried out in the name of religion. The petition had urged the Court to treat the issue as one of public health, environmental protection and constitutional morality, and not merely of animal welfare.
The matter was heard by a Bench of Justices Vikram Nath, R Mahadevan and Aparesh Kumar Singh. The reasons for the dismissal were not immediately available.
During the hearing, the petitioner argued that animal sacrifice finds no sanction in the true spirit of Hindu religious scriptures. Bali, it was contended, symbolises the sacrifice of human ignorance, ego and animalistic qualities, and not the killing of animals.
Counsel submitted that Hindu scriptures, including the Atharva Veda, Sama Veda and Yajur Veda, emphasise compassion towards living beings and describe the killing of innocent animals as a sin. Invoking the concept of Pashupati, the protector of animals, counsel argued that the very origins of Hindu religious thought support animal protection.
Explaining the symbolism of Navratri and Durga Puja, counsel argued that the battle between Goddess Durga and Mahishasura ought not to be read as a justification for killing buffaloes or other animals. The real sacrifice, counsel submitted, is of one's ego, ignorance, arrogance, greed and animalistic qualities.
Counsel also contested the claim that animal sacrifice is justified by religious tradition, contending that Shruti literature must prevail over Smriti literature wherever the two conflict.
Referring to temples such as Kalighat and Kamakhya, counsel argued that killing goats and other animals in the name of appeasing Goddess Durga runs contrary to the underlying spiritual message of worship.
Counsel further argued that the doctrine of parens patriae empowers constitutional courts to act as guardians of voiceless animals, who cannot speak for themselves.
Drawing a parallel with the abolition of human sacrifice, child marriage and practices such as Sati, counsel submitted that religious tradition cannot be pressed into service to justify practices that violate constitutional values.
On the constitutional front, counsel invoked Article 21 of the Constitution, arguing that the right to life and the protection of living creatures must also extend to animals.
Raising public health concerns, counsel warned that unregulated and brutal animal slaughter could heighten the risk of zoonotic diseases and of animal-to-human transmission of infections. Citing COVID-19, H1N1 and swine flu, counsel argued that the absence of proper animal protection and slaughter regulations could create serious public health risks.
Counsel also referred to alleged Brucella infections among animal handlers in West Bengal, submitting that 699 handlers had reportedly tested seropositive.
It was further argued that blood and animal waste from unregulated slaughter could contaminate water bodies, while improper disposal of meat waste could create further environmental and public health hazards.
To highlight the dangers of uncontrolled slaughter and waste disposal, counsel referred to environmental protection laws, including provisions of the Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act, 1974 and the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986.
In conclusion, counsel urged the Supreme Court to direct the Centre to take steps to prevent brutal animal killing, contending that the issue concerned not merely animal welfare but also public health, environmental protection and constitutional morality.
The Bench, however, dismissed the plea.
About the PIL
According to the petitioner, the practice of animal sacrifice continues in several parts of the country under the guise of religious tradition, even though multiple legal provisions prohibit cruelty to animals.
The petition argues that the authorities have failed to effectively enforce statutory provisions intended to protect animals from cruelty and unlawful killing. It seeks directions from the Court to ensure strict implementation of animal welfare laws and to restrain ritualistic killing of animals in temples and other places of worship.
The plea also contends that several religious narratives are often misinterpreted to justify the practice of animal sacrifice.
Referring to Hindu philosophical traditions, the petitioner states that Lord Shiva is revered as “Pashupati”, the protector and lord of all animals, emphasizing compassion and protection of living beings rather than their destruction. Similarly, mythological stories such as the slaying of Mahishasura by Goddess Durga or the defeat of the demon Raktabija are symbolic narratives, the petition claims, and cannot be used to justify the killing of animals in contemporary religious practices.
The petition relies on several statutory provisions aimed at preventing cruelty to animals. It refers to Article 51A(g) of the Constitution, which places a fundamental duty on every citizen to have compassion for living creatures. The petitioner has also cited provisions of the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals Act, 1960 and the Wildlife Protection Act, 1972 that criminalize acts of cruelty or harm to animals.
Case Title: Shruti Bist v. Ministry of Animal Husbandry
Bench: Justices Vikram Nath, R. Mahadevan and Aparesh Kumar Singh
Hearing Date: November 18, 2026
