Supreme Court Orders Medical Team To Examine 70-Year-Old Convict In 1981 Dumka Double Murder Case

Supreme Court orders medical examination of 70-year-old convict in a double murder case pending since 1981
The Supreme Court on Thursday asked Simon Soren, a 70-year-old convict on bail and the only one of six accused still alive in a double murder committed in Jharkhand's Dumka district in October 1981, to present himself for a medical examination at the district government hospital in Dumka, with the police directed to facilitate it.
The Bench of Justices J B Pardiwala and K Vinod Chandran directed, "The chief medical officer of the district government hospital, Dumka, Jharkhand, shall constitute a medical team to examine the appellant and file a report."
The Bench further directed the Superintendent of Police, Dumka, to ensure that the examination is facilitated through the Station House Officer of the police station within whose jurisdiction Soren resides. The matter has been listed for further hearing on March 3, 2027.
In its order, the Court noted that Soren had been granted bail on August 19 after it took note of his precarious health condition. The present direction is for a fresh medical report on him, to be filed by the team constituted by the Chief Medical Officer.
Appearing for Soren, Advocate Fauzia Shakil informed the Bench that the Supreme Court had, in July, in a petition filed by the National Legal Services Authority (NALSA), directed all States and Union Territories to formulate and notify, within three months, a comprehensive policy for the early or premature release of prisoners of advanced age or those who are terminally ill.
She sought that the hearing be deferred to enable the State of Jharkhand to formulate and notify such a policy. After directing the medical examination, the Bench posted the matter to March 2027.
On August 19, the same matter had led the Court to suspend Soren's sentence and direct his release, describing the litigation, then running for nearly half a century, as a "failure of the judicial system". It had also questioned why the Jharkhand High Court took more than 20 years to decide Soren's criminal appeal.
Six persons were arrayed as accused in 1981. The Court recorded that two of them died before charges were framed, and that three of the four convicts died while their appeal was pending before the High Court. It had observed, "The sole remaining accused, aged about 70 and troubled with multiple ailments, has surrendered into custody after the high court convicted him (in 2024)."
The Court had noted that Soren had spent, in all, only two years, four months and 12 days in custody, and that the crime had therefore gone unpunished. Balancing the gravity of the offence against the length of the proceedings, it had held, "Despite the horrendous crime of a double murder, we cannot close our eyes to the ordeal suffered by the accused in the last 45 years. Especially noting his medical condition and the affidavit of the state that the petitioner is admitted in the hospital, though in custody, we suspend the sentence and direct that the petitioner shall be released forthwith on the condition of his not committing any crime when on bail and on his personal surety."
The Court had also requisitioned the original record of the case, in physical as well as digital form, and requested the High Court and the trial court to transmit it within four weeks.
The Registrar General of the High Court had attributed the delay in the trial to the accused having absconded for six years. The Court, however, found no explanation for the 12 years it took for the trial to conclude after charges were framed in 1991. It had remarked, "We also notice from the report of the district and sessions judge that the case was transferred from one court to another five times in 11 years after the charge was framed."
The trial court awarded a sentence of life imprisonment in 2002. On 28 October 2024, the High Court dismissed the appeal and affirmed the sentence, following which Soren surrendered.
According to the prosecution, on 18 October 1981, Bibhuti Mandal, Banarsi Mandal and Kschir Sagar Mandal, along with their nephews Jagdish Mandal and Satyanarayan Mandal, went to Bhurundia village in Dumka for paddy harvesting.
Jagdish and Satyanarayan, who later became the informants, stated that as the group neared a river, a crowd of Santhals, gathered by drumbeats and armed with bows, arrows and axes, raised a call to kill members of the Mandal family. The Mandals tried to flee but were chased down.
It was alleged that Jethun Soren struck Bibhuti Mandal with an arrow, after which Simon Soren also struck him with an arrow, and that Banarsi Mandal was likewise struck with arrows by the two. When both men fell, Jagdish and Satyanarayan saw from a distance that they were hacked to death by the accused, the prosecution stated.
The matter will next be heard on March 3, 2027.
Case Title: Simon Soren v. The State of Jharkhand and Anr.
Bench: Justices J B Pardiwala and K Vinod Chandran
Order Date: November 19, 2026
