‘You Don’t Deserve The Chair’ Remark Against CJI Surya Kant Leads To Criminal Contempt Plea Before Supreme Court

SCBA seeks criminal contempt action against lawyer for telling CJI Surya Kant that he did not deserve the post and lacked integrity.
The Supreme Court Bar Association has filed a criminal contempt petition before the Supreme Court over scandalous remarks made by a counsel yesterday before the CJI Surya Kant led bench. The counsel seeking an urgent hearing was escorted out of the courtroom after he told CJI Kant that he did not deserve to occupy the post and lacked integrity.
SCBA Secretary Praghya Baghel and Joint Secretary Meenesh Dubey mentioned the plea before CJI Surya Kant's Bench today against the "You don't deserve to sit in the chair, you don't have integrity" remarks.
Supreme Court was informed today that Attorney General's consent for filing a petition to initiate criminal contempt proceedings against that lawyer was recieved. Issue be tagged along with Nikhil Wagle, Sanjay Raut matter listed today, the SCBA office bearers equested.
CJI Kant assured the fresh petition will be listed tomorrow.
Yesterday, CJI Kant's bench which sat at 2PM shut the audio and video after the counsel's submissions turned unsavory. The exchange that unfolded was as follows:
"CJI: Wait, we will see
Counsel continues to mention: This item was given to Mr. Justice in his office on 2 November. After 15 days, he has not given me reply. So I am forced to come before this court.
Justice Mohana: You can't mention anything like this
Counsel: No, I came as it's emergency. I'd like to submit my apology first. Please you just see the papers
CJI: We will see, you just wait
Counsel: No, I won't wait. You can't sit in that chair, you don't deserve. You don't have the integrity for that."
Supreme Court is also hearing a criminal contempt petition filed by the Supreme Court Bar Association (SCBA) over social media comments against Chief Justice of India Surya Kant made by journalist Nikhil Wagle and Shiv Sena (UBT) MP Sanjay Raut.
On October 16, the Court had issued notice in the Criminal Contempt Petition against Wagle and Raut over their comments against the Chief Justice of India and for committing gross criminal contempt of the Supreme Court. While issuing notice CJI Surya Kant had observed, "People don't understand that they are being trapped". In response, Solicitor General Tushar Mehta had submitted, "I support SCBA, many of them understand. Attempt is there, but many of them don't succeed." "Each one of them have come to court seeking rescue and if you still keep on condemning criticizing taking left and right, then let us see. Hope better sense will prevail. We have issued notice now," the CJI went on to observe.
The plea arises from a recent post made by Wagle on his X account @waglenikhil stating: “**** you CJI!”, in the context of a report concerning the Chief Justice of India declining a request to meet delegation of political parties led by Rahul Gandhi. SCBA has further alleged that upon the Chief Justice of India denying to meet the delegation of the political parties, Raut deliberately and intentionally made scandalous statements and made false scandalous allegations against the CJI, which were carried by IANS on the platform “X” with an accompanying video, wherein Raut alleged that Judges attend political programmes of the ruling party and accept dinners hosted by Chief Ministers.
Raut is also stated to have referred to the photographs of Judges playing Badminton with political figures in London and imputed allegations against the CJI and other Judges. Court has been told the statements are deliberate and intentional which are in fact false and contrary to records and were knowingly made to scandalise and diminish the authority of the Supreme Court.
Mentioning Date: November 17, 2026
Bench: CJI Kant, Justice Bagchi and Justice Mohana
