Article 142: Supreme Court Awards Rs 10 Lakh Each To Two Employees Wrongfully Terminated By School
| The Supreme Court invoked Article 142 to award Rs 10 lakh each to two former school employees for wrongful termination, despite deficiencies in their pleadings.
Supreme Court awards compensation for wrongful termination.
The Supreme Court has held that it can exercise its extraordinary powers under Article 142 of the Constitution to award compensation for wrongful termination, particularly where an employer disregards binding judicial directions and violates basic procedural safeguards in disciplinary proceedings.
A Bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and Sheel Nagu directed a private school in Maharashtra to pay Rs 10 lakh each to two former employees whose services were terminated nearly two decades ago over allegations of misappropriation of public money and related misconduct.
Court held that the termination orders were vitiated by the school's failure to lead evidence to substantiate the charges, despite being expressly granted liberty by the Bombay High Court, and its failure to furnish the inquiry reports to the employees before imposing the penalty.
"The failure to furnish final inquiry reports to a delinquent employee prior to the termination of their services constitutes a fatal procedural infirmity that renders the disciplinary action unsustainable," the Bench observed.
While acknowledging that the employees' writ petitions before the high court were inadequately drafted and did not specifically raise these grounds, Court invoked Article 142 to do complete justice. It observed that an order passed in brazen disregard of a binding judicial direction is a nullity.
Court noted that the employees had failed to specifically plead the school's non-compliance with a consent order passed by the Bombay High Court on March 17, 2005. They had also not specifically challenged the failure to lead evidence and the non-supply of inquiry reports in their writ petitions.
Emphasising the importance of proper pleadings, the Bench said, "A party is under a strict obligation to plead its case by making the requisite averments in support of the relief claimed. A court is under no obligation to entertain a plea or grant relief that is not supported by necessary assertions in the petition".
Court observed that, on a strict application of this principle, the appeals could have been dismissed because the employees had failed to raise the necessary grounds before the high court.
However, it expressed serious concern over the school's failure to comply with the consent order dated March 17, 2005, which had expressly permitted it to approach the School Tribunal for permission to lead evidence to substantiate the charges of misconduct.
The school's counsel fairly did not attempt to justify this omission.
As a result, Court observed that there was "no evidence worth the name" before the tribunal to establish the charges against the employees. It also found that the non-furnishing of the inquiry reports before imposing the major penalty of termination constituted a serious procedural infirmity.
The Bench reiterated that a high court ordinarily cannot grant relief under Article 226 to a party that has not pleaded an appropriate case. However, it held that an action or order wholly contrary to an express judicial direction passed by a competent court falls within an exceptional category and cannot be sustained.
Background of the case
Prithviraj S Singh, a senior clerk, and Shivadatta R Singh, a head clerk, were employed at the respondent school. Along with the then in-charge headmaster, they faced departmental proceedings over allegations of misappropriation and related misconduct.
An inquiry committee was constituted under the Maharashtra Employees of Private Schools (Conditions of Service) Rules, 1981. The employees objected to its composition. Although one member was replaced, their subsequent objection was rejected.
In protest, the two clerks abstained from the inquiry proceedings, which consequently proceeded ex parte.
Separate inquiry reports dated November 11, 2004 and November 13, 2004 held the charges against them to be established. However, neither the minutes of the proceedings nor the final inquiry reports were furnished to the employees before their services were terminated.
The employees subsequently approached the School Tribunal, Mumbai, under Section 9 of the Maharashtra Employees of Private Schools (Conditions of Service) Regulation Act, 1977, challenging their termination.
On March 10, 2005, the tribunal passed interim orders staying the terminations and directing the school to allow the employees to resume duty with 50% of their salaries.
The school challenged these orders before the Bombay High Court. On March 17, 2005, a single judge disposed of the petitions through a consent order.
Under the arrangement, the employees were to receive subsistence allowance during the pendency of their appeals. The school was expressly granted liberty to apply before the tribunal for permission to lead evidence to substantiate the charges of misconduct. The tribunal was also directed to expedite the appeals, while its interim orders were set aside without any expression of opinion on merits.
Despite being granted this liberty, the school never applied for permission to lead evidence. The tribunal also did not insist that the school produce oral evidence.
By separate orders dated July 19, 2006, the tribunal dismissed the employees' appeals. It held that the employees, having deliberately stayed away from the inquiry and failed to nominate their representatives to the committee, could not challenge the inquiry findings on merits.
The tribunal further relied on documentary material, including service books reflecting stoppage of increments and cash-book entries indicating delayed deposits of collections, to justify the terminations.
However, it did not return any finding on the charge of misappropriation itself, citing the pendency of criminal proceedings. No witness had been examined by the school.
The employees then approached the Bombay High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution. Their principal contention was that they were entitled to the same treatment as the in-charge headmaster, whose termination had been converted by the tribunal into compulsory retirement.
On June 17, 2016, the high court dismissed their writ petitions. It held that the headmaster stood on a different footing as he was nearing retirement after long service, whereas the two clerks had completed only a few years of service when the alleged misconduct occurred.
Before the Supreme Court, senior counsel appearing for the employees challenged the tribunal's orders on several grounds, including the school's failure to lead evidence and its failure to furnish the inquiry reports before terminating their services.
Court noted that these grounds had not been specifically pleaded in the writ petitions before the high court.
Nevertheless, considering the school's failure to comply with the consent order and the serious procedural infirmities in the disciplinary proceedings, the Bench held that the case warranted its intervention under Article 142.
It observed that the employees would have been entitled to greater relief had their writ petitions been properly drafted and the relevant grounds specifically raised.
Prithviraj S Singh had passed away during the pendency of the litigation, while Shivadatta R Singh was alive.
Court accordingly directed the school to pay Rs 10 lakh each to the two employees, or to the legal heirs of the deceased employee, as lump-sum compensation for wrongful termination.
The amount must be paid within three months of receipt of the order, Court ordered. The payment will constitute full and final settlement of all claims. In case of default, the school will be liable to pay interest at 12 per cent per annum until the amount is actually released, Court directed.
Case Title: Prithviraj S Singh (Deceased) Through LRs Etc Vs The Secretary, School Education Department, State of Maharashtra & Ors
Bench: Justices Dipankar Datta and Sheel Nagu
Date of Judgment: November 18, 2026