CJI BR Gavai Calls For Pragmatic Interpretation Of Law, Vows Transparency & Merit In Judicial Appointments

Speaking at a felicitation ceremony organised by the Bombay High Court, his alma mater as both a lawyer and judge, the CJI also stressed the judiciary’s duty to protect its hard-earned reputation and remain committed to constitutional values.

In the address, CJI Gavai shared that he had been receiving “a lot of complaints about the rude behaviour of some colleagues” and issued a stern reminder that judges must uphold the dignity of the judiciary.

“Being a judge is not a 10 to 5 job, it is an opportunity to serve society and the nation. Please do not do anything which brings disrepute to this august institution, whose reputation has been so laboriously built by generations of lawyers and judges,” he urged.

Quoting from past Supreme Court judgments, the CJI reiterated that the Constitution is a living document whose interpretation must evolve with societal needs. “The interpretation has to be pragmatic. It has to be one that suits the needs of society and addresses the problems faced by the present generation,” he emphasised.

On judicial appointments, CJI Gavai said that the independence of the judiciary remains paramount and non-negotiable. He assured that the Collegium system strives to strike a balance between merit, diversity, and inclusiveness.

“At no cost shall the independence of the judiciary be compromised. Merit will never be sacrificed,” he said, reaffirming the judiciary’s commitment to transparency in the appointment process.

The CJI also highlighted the impartial role of judges in the adjudicatory process, reminding them to remain unaffected by post-judgment developments. “A judge should work according to their conscience, the oath of office, and the law. Once a matter is decided, they should cut off their mind from it and not be perturbed by what happens next,” he remarked.

Reflecting on his years at the Bombay High Court, CJI Gavai expressed pride in the High Court’s legacy and its continued delivery of impactful judgments. “I feel proud when I hear praise for the judgments of the Bombay High Court,” he said.

In a clear message to the judiciary, the CJI called for humility, empathy, and an unwavering commitment to the rule of law. “We must be true to our oath and our commitment to justice. The judiciary’s reputation has been built by the tireless efforts of many before us; we must not falter in our duty to preserve it,” he concluded.

[Inputs: PTI]