Supreme Court seeks Centre's response on PIL over 11-year delay in finalising judges' appointment MoP

The Supreme Court on Wednesday issued notice to the Union Government on a public interest litigation that seeks a time-bound direction to finalise the revised Memorandum of Procedure (MoP) for appointing judges to the Supreme Court and High Courts, a process the Constitution Bench set in motion in December 2015 while hearing the National Judicial Appointments Commission (NJAC) case.

The Bench of Justices MM Sundresh and PB Varale issued notice on the writ petition filed by Lok Prahari, a registered society acting through its General Secretary, SN Shukla, a retired IAS officer and now an advocate. The petition, registered as Writ Petition (Civil) No. 1214 of 2026, arrays the Union of India, through the Secretary, Department of Justice, as Respondent No. 1, and the Chief Justice of India, through the Secretary General of the Supreme Court, as Respondent No. 2.

Besides finalisation of the MoP, the petition also asks the Court to direct that the minutes of collegium meetings at both the High Court and Supreme Court levels be made accessible under the Right to Information Act, 2005.

The matter had first come up on November 2 before a Bench of Justices PS Narasimha and Alok Aradhe. Justice Narasimha recused himself as he had earlier appeared as an Additional Solicitor General in the NJAC proceedings. The record of proceedings of that day notes that "one of us (P.S.Narasimha, J.) had appeared in a connected matter at one stage", and directed the Registry to place the matter before the Chief Justice for listing before another Bench.

The MoP is the set of documents that governs the appointment, elevation and transfer of judges of the High Courts and the Supreme Court.

The petition traces its case to the NJAC judgment of October 16, 2015, in which the Constitution Bench, by a separate "Order of the Court", decided to consider "the incorporation of additional appropriate measures, if any, for an improved working of the 'collegium system'". Hearings commenced on November 3, 2015.

It records that the then Attorney General, Mukul Rohatgi, urged the Court to desist, submitting that the formulation of the MoP "was an administrative responsibility which fell in the executive domain" and that the Court "neither had the expertise nor the wherewithal for proposing amendments in the existing Memorandum of Procedure (drawn on 30th June, 1999 by the Government of India)".

Accepting that suggestion, the Constitution Bench, by its order of December 16, 2015, directed in paragraph 10, "…the Government of India may finalize the existing Memorandum of Procedure by supplementing it in consultation with the Chief Justice of India. The Chief Justice of India will take a decision based on the unanimous view of the collegium comprising the four senior most puisne Judges of the Supreme Court."

The order, annexed to the petition, set out the factors to be considered under the heads of eligibility criteria, transparency in the appointment process, a Secretariat, and complaints. On transparency, it said that the eligibility criteria and procedure "ought to be made available on the website of the Court concerned and on the website of the department of Justice of the Government of India", and that the MoP "may provide for an appropriate procedure for minuting the discussions including recording the dissenting opinion of the Judges in the collegium while making provision for the confidentiality of the minutes consistent with the requirement of transparency in the system of appointment of Judges."

The petitioner states that the respondents were expected to "seize this opportunity of improving the existing opaque and subjective Collegium system for reinforcing the people's faith in the top judiciary of the country", but that "for some inexplicable reasons the aforesaid expectation has been belied and the crucial stipulation in the order dated 16.12.2015 of the Constitution Bench has remained unimplemented even in the last 10 years".

To show the history of the exchanges, the petition reproduces a 2020 order of the First Appellate Authority of the Department of Justice under the RTI Act. According to that order, the Government sent the draft MoP to the Chief Justice of India on March 22, 2016; the Chief Justice's response came on May 25, 2016 and July 1, 2016; the Government's views were conveyed on August 3, 2016; and the Supreme Court collegium's inputs were received on March 13, 2017.

That order further records that after the Supreme Court's judgment of July 4, 2017 in the suo motu contempt case against a Calcutta High Court judge, which "underlined the need to revisit the process of selection and appointment of Judges to the Constitutional Courts", the Government "conveyed the need to make improvement on the draft MoP to the Secretary General of the Supreme Court vide letter dated 11.07.2017." The petitioner remarks that the reply was "silent about the developments" after July 2017. "Perhaps, there was none," the petition adds.

The petition also quotes a June 2023 RTI reply of the Department of Justice, which said that the Government had proposed a Screening-cum-Evaluation Committee at the Supreme Court and High Court levels to assist the collegiums, but that "the Supreme Court did not agree to set up such Committees." The same reply stated that in a communication dated January 6, 2023 to the Chief Justice of India, the Government "emphasized the need to finalize the MoP in view of various judicial pronouncements" and suggested that the Search-cum-Evaluation Committee for Supreme Court judges and High Court Chief Justices "should consist of a representative nominated by Government of India". The file, the reply said, "includes papers marked as SECRET in nature" and could not be provided under the Official Secrets Act, 1923.

The petition sets out a series of RTI applications filed between 2020 and 2026 with the Department of Justice and the Supreme Court. Several requests made to the Department were transferred to the Supreme Court, which the petitioner says was done "even though the information sought related squarely to the Department of Justice and must be available in the department itself."

In 2023 and 2024, the Department declined information on the ground that matters regarding appointment of judges "are classified in nature and matters still under consideration of various Constitutional Authorities at different stages pertaining to the same cannot be disclosed to general public unless finalized & serves the interest of the Public at large."

In 2022, the Supreme Court's CPIO informed the petitioner that the collegium's comments on the Government's draft MoP had been sent on March 13, 2017, that the matter "was never discussed in the Full Court", and that the matter was under consideration of the Government and the Supreme Court.

In 2026, the petitioner asked the Supreme Court's CPIO what decision the Chief Justice had taken under the 2015 order. The CPIO replied on July 2, 2026 that "The information sought for is vague and/or presumptive in nature. Hence, no information." The petition contends that the CPIO "should have either provided the requisite information or clearly said that it does not exist."

In June 2026, the petitioner sought the "criteria/norms" adopted for shortlisting advocates, High Court judges and Chief Justices, and for judging the inter se merit of candidates for the High Courts and the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court's CPIO, in a reply dated July 10, 2026, referred the petitioner to the Constitution, the judgments reported in 1993, 1998 and 2016, and the MoP available on the Department of Justice website. The petitioner says that "none of the sources mentioned in the reply of the CPIO contain the information sought", which leads to "the obvious conclusion that requisite information does not exist." Both first appeals were dismissed on August 25, 2026.

On this basis, the synopsis to the petition states, "…the total lack of criteria for short listing/selection and non recording of reasons for selection/leaving out coupled with the unofficial collaboration between the Collegium and the Executive makes appointments to constitutional courts highly partisan, opaque, and often arbitrary. As such, the existing mechanism and its processes are incapable of identifying the cleanest and most meritorious candidates."

The petition relies on published commentary to support this. It quotes an article by Senior Advocate Sanjay Hegde, who appeared for the petitioner on November 2, which observed that "Supreme Court appointments, the highest judicial decisions in the land, can hinge not on settled criteria or institutional consensus, but on who retires when. That is not independence. It is fragility disguised as discretion." It also quotes Senior Advocate and former High Court Chief Justice Dr S Muralidhar, who reportedly said at a memorial lecture in August 2026 that the appointment process was compounded by "the vagueness as to the criteria, a lack of transparency and an overall inefficiency."

Paragraph 61 of the petition sets out the measures that Lok Prahari had first sent to the Ministry of Law and Justice by letter dated December 24, 2015, which the petition says "was not even acknowledged". It states that the selection procedure "must be objective, fair and transparent so that only the best persons of highest competence and integrity (both financial and intellectual) are selected."

The suggestions include defined eligibility criteria for High Court judges, public notice of vacancies inviting applications, a standard proforma for biodata, affidavits by candidates disclosing family relationships with judges and politicians, political affiliation and assets, and collegium minutes that "clearly state the norm(s) adopted for judging the inter se suitability of the candidates considered" and record "the reasons for preferring the selected persons in the preference to those left out." It also proposes that "in case of lack of unanimity among the Collegium members on any issue/case the matter be decided by the majority view of the full Court", and that the minutes of the shortlisting committee and collegium meetings "must be subject to RTI".

Among its grounds, the petition says that "ten years time was more than enough to comply with the order dated 16.12.2015 of the Constitution Bench", and that "it is a case of persistent breach of duty on the part of the respondent no.1". Relying on Subrata Roy Sahara v. Union of India, it submits that "Disobedience of orders of a Court strikes at the very root of the rule of law, on which the judicial system rests."

It also invokes Article 14, contending that the process for selecting judges must be "objective, fair and transparent to meet the requirement of Article 14 of the Constitution", and cites the Constitution Bench ruling on the appointment of the Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioners on the need for a selection process that secures "impartiality, fearlessness, transparency and parity". This, the petition says, "is evidently more necessary in the case of judges of constitutional courts and especially the Apex Court since their orders are final."

Reliefs sought

The petitioner has prayed for a direction to the Chief Justice of India, as Respondent No. 2, to take a decision within a month on necessary changes to the existing MoP based on the unanimous view of the collegium, taking into consideration the factors in paragraph 10 of the December 16, 2015 order. It has further sought a writ of mandamus to the Union Government to finalise the MoP within a month thereafter, by supplementing it in consultation with the Chief Justice of India.

The petition also asks the Court to direct that the respondents consider the suggestions in paragraphs 57, 58 and 61 of the petition and the two annexed articles while finalising the MoP, and that, "to ensure transparency and objectivity of the selection process the minutes of the meetings of the High Court and Supreme Court Collegiums for selection of judges for High Courts and Supreme Court shall be accessible under the RTI Act." Costs have also been sought.

Case Title: Lok Prahari v. Union of India & Anr.

Bench: Justices MM Sundresh and PB Varale

Hearing Date: November 18, 2026

Tags: