Sonia Gandhi Electoral Roll Case: Delhi Court Seeks Police Report On FIR Plea Over 1980 Voter List Entry

Delhi Court seeks police report on plea alleging Sonia Gandhi was a voter before she was a citizen
A Delhi Court on Wednesday called for an Action Taken Report (ATR) from the Delhi Police on a complaint seeking registration of an FIR against Congress leader Sonia Gandhi, which alleges that her name was entered in the electoral roll of the New Delhi constituency in 1980 on the strength of forged documents, three years before she became an Indian citizen.
Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate (ACJM) Vinod Joshi of the Rouse Avenue Courts passed the order and listed the matter for further hearing on November 28.
The direction comes on remand. Special Judge Vishal Gogne had earlier set aside the magisterial order declining to direct registration of an FIR, holding it to be a "complete non-speaking order, lacking appropriate reasons", and had sent the application back to the ACJM for fresh consideration.
The complaint has been filed by one Vikas Tripathi. His case is that Gandhi's name appeared in the electoral roll of the New Delhi constituency in 1980, whereas she acquired Indian citizenship only in 1983. According to the complainant, her name was deleted from the roll in 1982 and entered again in 1983.
Tripathi alleges that forged documents were used to secure the 1980 inclusion, and on that basis his counsel has pressed for registration of an FIR. These remain allegations; no court has returned any finding on them.
When the application first came up, the magisterial court refused to direct registration of an FIR. It held that entertaining the plea would amount to encroaching upon the jurisdiction of the Election Commission of India.
The court also found the material placed before it wanting. It observed that "mere bald assertions, unaccompanied by the essential particulars required to attract the statutory elements of cheating or forgery, cannot substitute a legally sustainable accusation". The complainant, it noted, was relying solely on a photocopy of an alleged extract of an uncertified electoral roll of 1980.
Tripathi challenged that order before the Sessions Court. Special Judge Gogne set it aside as non-speaking, but declined to decide the prayer for an FIR himself.
The Court held that it could not step into the shoes of the ACJM to consider a prayer for registration of an FIR under Section 175(3) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (BNSS). That exercise, it said, can be performed only by the Magistrate, and "a revisional court cannot assume the character of the judicial magistrate".
The matter was accordingly remanded to the ACJM, with a direction to pass a speaking order after hearing the parties, conducting an inquiry, and hearing the police officer concerned.
The direction tracks the scheme of Section 175(3) BNSS. Unlike its predecessor, Section 156(3) of the Code of Criminal Procedure, the provision requires the Magistrate, before ordering investigation, to consider an application supported by affidavit, and empowers the Magistrate to make such inquiry as is considered necessary and to consider the submissions of the police officer.
Acting on the remand, ACJM Joshi has now sought the police's report. The matter will be heard next on November 28.
Background
In December 2025, a Session court had issued notice to Congress leader and MP Sonia Gandhi in the revision petition. Previously on September 11, 2025 a Delhi Court had dismissed a criminal complaint seeking registration of an FIR against Congress leader Sonia Gandhi over the alleged inclusion of her name in the 1980 electoral roll before she acquired Indian citizenship.
The complaint invoked provisions of the Indian Penal Code, Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, and the Representation of the People Act, 1950, alleging cheating, forgery, and false declaration. The informant relied on a photocopy of an electoral roll extract and news reports to claim that Gandhi was registered as a voter in New Delhi in 1980, despite being granted Indian citizenship only in 1983 under Section 5(1)(c) of the Citizenship Act, 1955.
Rejecting the plea, ACJM Vaibhav Chaurasia had observed that the allegations lacked the fundamental ingredients to constitute the offences of cheating or forgery and were based on “mere bald assertions” without legally sustainable evidence. The Court held that the complaint was an attempt to misuse criminal law by projecting an ordinary dispute as a criminal matter to invoke its jurisdiction. "Such a course, in substance, amounts to a misuse of the process of law by projecting a civil or ordinary dispute in the garb of criminality, solely to create a jurisdiction where none exists," it said.
Most significantly, the Court had underscored that it had no authority to adjudicate issues relating to citizenship or voter eligibility. “This Court is not empowered to adjudicate upon questions which, by express constitutional and statutory mandate, fall within the exclusive domain of the Central Government in matters relating to citizenship in view of Article 11 of the Constitution of India, 1950, and the Citizenship Act, 1955,” the order had stated.
The Court further had emphasized that the determination of inclusion or exclusion from electoral rolls lies solely with the Election Commission of India under the Representation of the People Act, 1950 and 1951. Any interference by the Court, it said, would amount to “unwarranted transgression” into the constitutional functions of the competent authorities and a violation of Article 329 of the Constitution.
The criminal complaint filed by Advocate Vikas Tripathi sought a thorough investigation into the purported irregularity, which, if proven, could have legal ramifications under the Representation of the People Act. Tripathi approached the Court under relevant criminal provisions, requesting that authorities initiate an inquiry into the matter. “The reason for the deletion is nowhere to be found. There can be two reasons, either someone takes the citizenship of another country or files a Form 8 (application for correction in particulars). But the prerequisite is that the person has to be a citizen,” Narang had said. He had questioned what documents were submitted to the Election Commission when her name was first included in 1980.
Bench: ACJM Vinod Joshi
Hearing Date: November 18, 2026
