Calcutta HC Issues Criminal Contempt Show-Cause Notice To TMC's Abhishek Banerjee Over Judges "With BJP" Remark
| Justice Krishna Rao asks the TMC MP to explain within 15 days why he should not be punished for criminal contempt over interview remarks allegedly suggesting that judges were working under pressure of the BJP
Calcutta High Court has initiated suo motu criminal contempt proceedings over TMC leader Banerjee's remarks allegedly questioning the political impartiality of judges
The Calcutta High Court has issued a show-cause notice to Trinamool Congress (TMC) MP Abhishek Banerjee in suo motu criminal contempt proceedings over his remarks allegedly questioning the political impartiality of judges and suggesting that some members of the judiciary were aligned with the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP).
A Single Bench of Justice Krishna Rao has directed Banerjee to explain within 15 days why he should not be punished for criminal contempt. The matter has been listed for hearing on December 8.
The proceedings arise from an interview in which Banerjee allegedly suggested that the High Court had kept his plea seeking enhancement of security cover pending because the judges were “with” the BJP.
The State had alleged that the remarks cast aspersions on the impartiality of the judiciary and amounted to criminal contempt. During the hearing, Additional Advocate General Billwadal Bhattacharyya submitted that there was no scope for merely issuing a show-cause notice and that the Court would have to issue a formal contempt motion.
Justice Rao, however, made clear that he intended to issue a show-cause notice. The Court thereafter called upon Banerjee to explain within 15 days why he should not be punished for criminal contempt.
The notice gives the TMC MP an opportunity to respond to the allegations. The Court has not yet returned any finding of guilt or imposed punishment.
Interview remarks triggered controversy during security plea hearing
The contempt proceedings stem from the hearing of Banerjee's petition challenging the West Bengal Government's decision to downgrade his security cover from Z+ to X category.
During the hearing on November 12, the State's counsel, Additional Advocate General Billwadal Bhattacharyya, referred to an interview given by Banerjee and placed its transcript and a pen drive containing the recording before the Court.
He alleged that the MP had questioned the impartiality of judges and urged the Court to initiate suo motu criminal contempt proceedings.
Banerjee's counsel opposed the State's submissions, arguing that the interview had no bearing on the security-related plea. He sought to explain the remarks in the context of his client's concerns over alleged attacks and threats to his family.
Justice Rao had then questioned the TMC MP's alleged suggestion that judges were politically aligned with the BJP. "Who are the judges with the BJP and who aren't? Since he is so intelligent, let him give a list. I will see" the Court had remarked.
The Judge had also observed that Banerjee was effectively "writing the ACR of the judges". The Court had, however, clarified that the controversy surrounding the interview would not influence its consideration of the separate petition concerning his security arrangements.
In a separate direction concerning Banerjee's security plea, Justice Rao has asked the West Bengal Government's security review committee to convene and decide within two weeks whether his security arrangements need to be enhanced.
Banerjee had challenged the reduction of his security cover from Z+ to X category, alleging that the decision was politically motivated. He had also cited several alleged attacks and threats to his safety between May 30 and November 7.
The Court directed the State's security authorities to take these incidents into account while reviewing his threat perception. The criminal contempt proceedings and the security review are separate issues before the High Court.