Retired Officials Appointed To Public Service Commissions: SC Upholds 'Pay Minus Pension' Principle
| Supreme Court upholds Regulation 7(2) of the Uttarakhand PSC Regulations, 2004, allowing pension deductions from salaries of retired government officials appointed to the Commission, holding that Articles 14 and 39(d) are not violated.
Supreme Court upholds pension deduction for retired PSC members.
The Supreme Court has held that the principle of equal pay for equal work is not violated by a regulation providing for the deduction of pension earned from previous government service from the salary payable for a post-retirement appointment.
A Bench of Justices S V N Bhatti and N V Anjaria observed that such a deduction does not amount to withdrawal of pension but merely places it in temporary abeyance during the tenure of the new office.
Court further held that a person who accepts an appointment with full knowledge of the applicable service regulations and enjoys the benefits of the post cannot subsequently challenge the validity of those regulations or the conditions of service attached to it.
Setting aside a 2010 judgment of the Uttarakhand High Court, the Supreme Court upheld the validity of Regulation 7(2) of the Uttarakhand Public Service Commission (Conditions of Service) Regulations, 2004, which provides for deduction of pension from the salary of retired government officials appointed as Chairman or Members of the Commission.
The high court had declared the provision ultra vires Article 14 read with Article 39(d) of the Constitution.
Court explained that the principle of 'pay minus pension' was applied while fixing the salary of the original petitioners, who had been appointed to the Uttarakhand Public Service Commission after retirement from government service.
It held that the doctrine of equal pay for equal work had no relevance to the issue, as the deduction of pension did not amount to unequal remuneration for the same work.
"The High Court wholly misdirected itself in reasoning that the principle of 'equal pay for equal work' was violated and resultantly Regulation 7(2) was ultra vires Articles 14 and 39(d) of the Constitution. In no way, thus, the provision of Regulation 7(2), its application and operation to the cases like that of the original petitioners could be said to be ultra vires," the Bench held.
Background
The case arose from two appeals filed by the State of Uttarakhand challenging the high court's judgment dated April 15, 2010.
Respondent No. 1, the original petitioner, Lieutenant General (Retired) M C Bhandari, retired from the Indian Army on August 30, 2006, upon attaining the age of superannuation.
He was subsequently appointed Chairman of the Uttarakhand Public Service Commission on November 3, 2006, and assumed office on November 24, 2006.
The order fixing his salary specified that the pension payable to him for his previous service as Lieutenant General would be deducted from his salary as Chairman.
Accordingly, by an order dated December 19, 2006, the Finance Controller of the Uttarakhand PSC fixed his salary after deducting Rs 17,627 towards the pension he was receiving.
After his representation against the deduction was rejected, he approached the high court, challenging Regulation 7(2) of the 2004 Regulations. He contended that the provision violated Article 14 of the Constitution and that the orders deducting his pension from his salary were illegal.
A similar petition was filed by another PSC Member, who had retired from the post of Additional Secretary and was aggrieved by the deduction of his pension from his salary.
The high court allowed both petitions.
Considering the appeals, the Supreme Court noted that Article 318 of the Constitution empowers the Governor to frame regulations determining the number of members of a State Public Service Commission and their conditions of service.
It also provides that the conditions of service of a member of a Public Service Commission cannot be varied to their disadvantage after appointment.
The Bench noted that the Uttarakhand Public Service Commission Regulations were framed under Article 318 and notified on December 16, 2004.
It further observed that Regulation 7(2) provided for the application of the 'pay minus pension' principle while determining the salary of persons appointed to the Commission after retirement.
The respondents had argued that an Office Memorandum issued on September 16, 2008, could not be applied retrospectively to their appointments.
The memorandum clarified that when a Central or State Government officer assumes office as Chairman or Member of the Uttarakhand PSC after retirement, the pension payable immediately before assuming office, except disability or injury pension, would be deducted from the basic pay admissible to the new post.
Rejecting the argument, the Bench observed that the Regulations were already in force when the original petitioners were appointed in 2006 and Regulation 7 was applicable to them.
"The contention has no legs to stand. When the original petitioners appointed as Chairman and Member, respectively, of the Uttarakhand PSC, admittedly, the Uttarakhand Public Service Commission Regulations were in force and Regulation 7 was applicable," the Bench said.
It further held that the Office Memorandum did not introduce a new condition retrospectively. At best, it operated retroactively by reflecting the decision taken by the Governor.
Court also observed that accepting the respondents' interpretation would lead to absurd consequences, as adding the pension to the salary could result in their total remuneration exceeding the actual salary admissible to the post, potentially even surpassing the salary of the highest post.
The Bench also emphasised that the original petitioners had accepted their appointments with full knowledge of the applicable Regulations and could not subsequently challenge the service conditions attached to those posts.
"Having accepted the appointment to the respective posts with open eyes and knowledge and having assumed the office with consciousness... it was not permissible for them to claim a different chord," the Bench observed.
Drawing an analogy with the settled principle that a candidate who participates in a selection process or a student who appears for an examination cannot subsequently challenge the rules governing that process, Court said the same principle applies to government employees who accept appointments.
An employee cannot be permitted to subsequently resile from or question the service conditions and regulations attached to the post voluntarily accepted, it added.
The Bench further noted that the original petitioners were appointed in 2006, enjoyed the benefits of their respective posts for more than two years and challenged the applicability of Regulation 7(2) only towards the fag end of their tenure.
It held that the principle of acquiescence would also operate against them.
"The principle of acquiescence would operate so as not to permit the original petitioners to raise the challenge," the Bench held.
Finding that the high court had committed a manifest error in declaring Regulation 7(2) unconstitutional and granting relief to the petitioners, the Supreme Court set aside its judgment, holding that it was not sustainable in law.
Case Title: State of Uttarakhand Thr Chief Secretary & Ors Vs M N Bhandari
Bench: Justices S V N Bhatti and N V Anjaria
Date of Judgment: November 04, 2026