Judges, not AI, must remain in the driver's seat of justice, says Senior Advocate Rajshekhar Rao

Artificial intelligence may make courts faster and easier to reach, but the responsibility for deciding cases must stay with a human judge, Senior Advocate Rajshekhar Rao told law students, faculty and judges at the inaugural JusTech National Conclave at Dharmashastra National Law University (DNLU), Jabalpur.

Speaking at a session on the interplay between artificial intelligence and the future of justice, Rao said, "The question is not whether artificial intelligence will transform the judiciary. It almost certainly will. The more consequential question to my mind is who or what … should be in the driver's seat when justice is being administered." His answer was unequivocal: "it is the judge."

Rao, who said this was his first visit to Jabalpur, addressed his remarks "largely [to] the younger lot". He organised the speech around three questions: the potential of AI for access to justice in India, the constitutional and institutional risks of adopting it, and how the legal profession, the judiciary and institutions should respond.

Rao opened with an account of a legal-aid matter he argued as a young lawyer before the late Justice Valmiki Mehta of the Delhi High Court on 23 December 2011, the last working day before the winter break. He appeared for a woman with a minor child who had been evicted from her matrimonial home by her father-in-law. At the time, he said, "the Supreme Court was rather more emphatic that a daughter-in-law had no claim to the estate of her in-laws."

Rao recalled that, moments before his matter was called, Justice Mehta had admonished a senior advocate in an earlier item: "This is the problem with you lawyers. you don't advise your clients. How can you advise a lady that she has a right in her father-in-law's estate?"

When Rao rose to say he had "a slightly different point to make", the judge replied, "Of course you do, young man, but you haven't made it." Justice Mehta then pointed him to the child's claim, Rao said: "You have founded your case on the right of the mother. You have forgotten about the right of her child. Have you seen the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act? According to you the father is unavailable and he's not been seen for the last seven plus years. Isn't there a presumption that he is dead? And is there no right that the minor has in the estate of his grandfather?"

The judge asked him to file an affidavit raising additional grounds the same day. Rao said that when he returned, Justice Mehta told his client, "Madam, the law is entirely against you. Your young man has also failed you. This is all I can do to try and give you justice. I'm admitting your petition. Make sure you educate your son so that he can take care of you."

The woman, Rao said, left the house "with a settlement in 2023 with a son who's now an engineer who's looking after his mother." He described it as "the defining aspect of what justice is."

He later returned to the episode to make his point about technology, "The technology would have probably said sorry supreme court says this is a daughter-in-law asking for a right in a father-in-law's estate. No relief. would not have taken that additional step forward and found a way to do justice."

Rao said he expected a human presence on the bench "at least in our lifetime hopefully and going forward always", a presence that takes an oath under the Constitution as a judge of a High Court or the Supreme Court. That oath, he said, "formally insulates this entire structure."

He framed the debate as "the classic tussle between logic and experience", contrasting Sir Edward Coke's dictum that "reason is the life of the law. Nay the common law itself is nothing else but reason" with Oliver Wendell Holmes's view that "The life of the law has not been logic. It has been experience."

"My experience was to demonstrate that the edifice of justice is humanity and therefore technology may assist the administration of justice. It may improve its efficiency, widen its reach and make it more accessible … But the responsibility for administering justice cannot be outsourced. It must remain firmly rooted in the judge and more importantly must remain human," he said.

Rao was careful to add that he was not opposed to change: "I am not a Luddite. I am not a dinosaur in terms of technological progress. I'm only asking that we preserve the character of the judiciary and its fundamental tenets while we embrace change." Noting that Madhya Pradesh is known as "Hindustan ka dil", he remarked that to do justice "you must have a heart".

On the first question, Rao described technology as "an instrument of … democratizing justice". He said Indian courts had embraced technology during the Covid-19 pandemic in a way that made "the west look at us and marvel", and that visitors from abroad were surprised that "we don't use a piece of paper in most of our courtrooms today."

Referring to Articles 39A, 14 and 21, he said "access to justice remains the foundational basis that the constitution guarantees to every citizen", and that legal-aid programmes had so far "scratched the surface".

AI, he said, had helped translate judgments, prepare pleadings and procedural documents, make legal information accessible to people who cannot navigate legal databases, assist persons with disabilities, and improve filing and procedural efficiency. It reduces "the mundane aspects of the law" so that lawyers and judges can focus on the real issues. "These are not marginal improvements. They have the potential to alter economics of accessing justice," he said.

He cited Odisha, where, he said, the then Chief Justice set up access points at district courts so that lawyers across the State could appear before the High Court directly. A litigant no longer had "to rely on somebody who had to rely on somebody else", and his lawyer could articulate his grievance in a manner "not only correct in law but also carried with it the empathy that it deserved." Rao said the principle that a litigant must be treated with empathy had "got lost in translation" somewhere in the push to manage numbers, and technology could help bring it back.

Quoting figures he attributed to the Ministry of Law and Justice in July 2026, Rao said 817 of Odisha's 845 courts had been equipped with ICT infrastructure and video-conferencing facilities, enabling about 7.61 lakh virtual hearings till June 2026. He called this "really the tip of the iceberg", adding, "We have miles … to go before we sleep."

Rao cautioned against equating technology with justice. "Access to a chatbot is not access to justice. Access to a translated document does not necessarily mean that the person has the right translation. A word misunderstood by the chatbot alters the entire basis of the judgment. And that is why we have this whole aspect of hallucination," he said.

Turning to the constitutional risks, Rao said, "Efficiency cannot become a substitute for adjudication. There is a fundamental distinction between the judge and the machine. Adjudication is not simply the processing of information. It involves the evaluation of competing claims, assessment of evidence, interpretation of legal principles, the application of law to facts, and more importantly, the exercise of judicial discretion."

He illustrated the point with the familiar opening words of definition clauses, "unless the context otherwise requires", which show that "the same word can have multiple meanings in the same statute depending upon where it is placed." He said he was "not certain that technology at present and in the near future has the ability to make that distinction or will have the ability to make a choice between two competing interpretations when called upon to do so at a defining moment."

"The legitimacy of judicial power rests not only upon the correctness of the result but upon the process through which that result is reached," Rao said. The litigant must have confidence that "he or she has been heard … through a fair process and more importantly that the decision is vested and has in fact been taken by the person who's been conferred with the constitutional authority to take that decision."

Rao briefly flagged three further concerns. On bias, he said, "The technology is dependent on the input that it receives. We are still not certain as to what inputs go in." On opacity, he said that "A judge's experiences define his or her response to a problem. Technology is an aid therefore and only helps that experience to address a situation" more efficiently.

On privacy, he described checking in for his flight that day, when the DigiYatra app asked him to consent to eight data points, failing which he "would have had to stand in line." He asked: "Do I have the confidence as a litigant that the information that I'm feeding in is available only to those that matter and is not going to be misused or is not going to be used elsewhere?" He also pointed to "this lingering debate on the right to be forgotten."

Rao referred to recent cautions from the courts on AI misuse, including a Madhya Pradesh High Court order dealing with "a hallucinated citation in a counter affidavit filed by the state government", and a Supreme Court ruling delivered two days before the Conclave.

On how institutions should respond, Rao described the draft regulations on the use of AI in courts as "one of the most defining moments", because "any use of technology … must be sanctioned right from the very top" and "must be clear and consistent so that there is no ambiguity for any lawyer" wherever he practises. "The beauty of our system is you can be a lawyer who's enrolled in the bar council of Nagaland and still be able to practice in the highest court in the land. There must be one standard and that standard fortunately is now being laid down," he said.

He credited the Supreme Court's practice of keeping its judgments on JUDIS as a single official, verifiable database, and noted that a QR code can now be used "to verify whether the judgment is authentic or not."

He also warned young lawyers against over-reliance on devices, asking what they would do if an iPad or computer stopped working, something he said had happened to him "2 minutes before I came up." He asked whether they could still argue the case, remember the page numbers and fulfil "the most solemn obligation that as lawyers we have to assist the judge there to do complete justice."

Rao told students that "no matter what technology you use, no matter what tools you use, the buck ultimately does stop with us." The test, he said, is whether one allows AI "to become a slave or … a master".

"A lawyer who uses AI to identify authorities must read the judgments," he said, warning that an opponent "who relies on a summary may miss that one little comma in a document which defines the entire outcome of that case."

He concluded, "The lawyer of the future will certainly need technological competence. But technological competence without legal judgment will be a dangerous combination. We have to build in safeguards. We have to hold ourselves accountable. Once we start doing that, the system works for itself."

Tags: