“Male Society Needs To Introspect”: Justice BV Nagarathna Says Women’s Empowerment Incomplete Without Right To Be Born, Inherit And Be Safe
| Delivering the inaugural Cornelia Sorabji Memorial Lecture at Somerville College, Justice B V Nagarathna said women in high office did not mean equality had been achieved, warned that more laws alone could not secure access to justice, and pressed for one-third reservation for women lawyers on government panels
Justice Nagarathna says women's empowerment remains incomplete without the right to be born, learn, inherit and be safe
Supreme Court judge Justice B V Nagarathna has said that women's empowerment in India will remain incomplete unless every girl is assured the right to be born, to be educated, to choose whom she marries, to pursue a career, to inherit property and to be safe at home, at the workplace and on a public street, and that Indian society, "particularly the male society", must introspect if the constitutional promise to women is to be realised.
Justice Nagarathna was delivering the inaugural Cornelia Sorabji Memorial Lecture at Somerville College, University of Oxford, on Wednesday. The lecture was titled "The Doors She Opened: Cornelia Sorabji and the Progress of Women's Rights in India". Sorabji is widely recognised as the first woman to practise law in India.
"The right to be born as a girl child, the right to education, marital choice, to pursue a career of one's choice, the right to inherit property and safe conditions for women both at home as well as in the workplace and most importantly, on a public street are salient aspects which would empower women to a large extent in India," she said.
If women were able to fulfil their choices and goals, she said, the word "empowerment" itself would pale into insignificance. "Every girl child must have the right to be born and the right to pursue her choices," she added.
The most important lesson of Sorabji's life, according to Justice Nagarathna, is that access to justice depends on the ability to transform knowledge into effective agency. "The doors have been opened by Cornelia. Our responsibility is to ensure that they remain open for women," she said.
Speaking of her own path, the judge said: "I have had the benefit of education and a career to pursue, but there are many women in India who find it difficult to pursue education or have a career, even though well qualified. Indian society, particularly the male society, needs to introspect on this critical aspect."
Justice Nagarathna said she has consistently advocated reserving one-third of the seats on government panels for women lawyers, including panels representing public sector undertakings, and in legal aid.
"The door of the legal profession must, after all, remain open not only to entry, but to professional advancement and institutional leadership," she said.
She pointed out that the 73rd and 74th Constitutional Amendments reserved not less than one-third of seats for women in panchayats and municipalities, and that the Constitution (106th Amendment) Act, 2023 extended the principle to the Lok Sabha and the State Legislative Assemblies. In her home State of Karnataka, she noted, the reservation for women in local bodies is not less than 50 per cent.
Cautioning against a purely celebratory reading of progress, Justice Nagarathna said the presence of women in high public offices does not mean equality has been achieved. "A woman may hold a senior position while other women remain excluded from education, employment, property or effective legal remedies," she said.
A constitutional guarantee, she observed, "may be enforceable in theory, while the cost, delay or social consequences of litigation make its practical exercise difficult". A judgment cannot, by itself, ensure that every workplace is safe, that every girl is educated or that every victim of domestic violence secures timely protection, she said.
"It would surely be a mistake to measure the progress of Indian women's rights only by the number of discriminatory provisions that have been struck down or the beneficial statutes that have been enacted. Even on this measure, the Indian constitutional project remains unfinished. Even otherwise, there are other grave concerns," Justice Nagarathna said.
Those "grave concerns", she said, include women's safety, access to justice and economic equality.
"The question is whether a woman can invoke the protection of the law without the fear of stigma, retaliation or economic insecurity. This challenge cannot be overcome by simply enacting more laws," she said.
Equality, she said, must be attentive to the differences among women, including those of class, disability, religion, region and economic circumstances. "There is no single experience of being a woman," she said.
She also flagged the gap between legal change and social attitudes. "Finally, there is the question of society and culture. Laws may change more quickly than the assumptions held by those to whom it applies," she said.
Tracing the Supreme Court's approach to women's rights, Justice Nagarathna said the Court was initially cautious on gender equality. She referred to Air India v. Nergesh Meerza (1981), in which the Court struck down the rule providing for automatic termination of air hostesses on their first pregnancy.
She contrasted this with C B Muthamma v. Union of India (1979), in which Justice V R Krishna Iyer held that marriage cannot justify restrictions applied exclusively to women.
Among the later landmarks, she listed the Shah Bano case on maintenance for divorced Muslim women; the Vishaka guidelines on sexual harassment at the workplace, later replaced by the 2013 law; Anuj Garg, on "protective paternalism"; and the decisions granting permanent commission to women officers in the Army and the Navy.
Justice Nagarathna also referred to judgments she authored or was a part of. In Association of Old Settlers of Sikkim v. Union of India (2023), the Court struck down a tax provision that denied an exemption to Sikkimese women who marry non-Sikkimese men. In Prabha Tyagi v. Kamlesh Devi (2022), the Court held that a woman need not have been residing with her husband at the time of seeking relief under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005.
Referring to the Deepika Singh ruling on maternity leave, she said, "Pregnancy and childbirth ought not to compel women to choose between employment and motherhood."
Source: PTI