Husband's false defence strengthens evidence in wife's murder case, says Supreme Court.

The Supreme Court has held that when a woman dies an unnatural death inside her matrimonial home while in the exclusive company of her husband, the husband cannot escape liability by remaining silent or offering an implausible explanation. Court said Section 106 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (Section 109 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023) places the burden on him to explain the circumstances leading to her death.

Section 106 of the IEA states that when any fact is especially within the knowledge of a person, the burden of proving that fact lies on that person.

A Bench of Justices Sandeep Mehta and Devendra Kumar Upadhyaya said that a demonstrably false defence, particularly when contradicted by medical evidence, constitutes an additional incriminating link in the chain of circumstantial evidence and can help establish the charge of murder.

Court made the observation while upholding the Bombay High Court's decision to overturn the acquittal of Ramkishan Digambar Jadhav for murdering his wife within nine months of their marriage. It upheld his conviction under Section 302 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 [Section 103(1) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023], and the sentence of life imprisonment.

Court also upheld the convictions of Jadhav, his father and brother for dowry death and cruelty.

The prosecution's case was that Jadhav's wife, Vimalbai, died an unnatural death at their matrimonial home on February 1, 1996, barely nine months after their marriage on May 12, 1995.

The prosecution alleged that she was subjected to continuous physical and mental cruelty over demands for a television, tape deck, a plot of land in the MIDC area and Rs 50,000 to help her husband secure employment.

On the night of the incident, Jadhav informed Vimalbai's brother, Narayan, that she was experiencing convulsions and was being taken to Naigaon for treatment. However, when Narayan and other family members reached the spot, they found Vimalbai lying lifeless in a bullock cart, with blood oozing from her nostrils and fingers. Doctors at Naigaon Hospital declared her brought dead.

The post-mortem examination established that she had died due to asphyxia caused by throttling.

Before the Supreme Court, Jadhav claimed that Vimalbai had suffered an epileptic seizure while he was engaging in sexual intercourse with her, resulting in her accidental death.

Rejecting this explanation, Court noted that the medical jurist had categorically ruled out the possibility of an epileptic seizure, pointing out that there was no lockjaw or displacement of the tongue and that the internal injuries to the neck could not have been caused by such a seizure.

Court observed that the defence was consequently found to be false and concocted by both the trial court and the high court.

It further noted that none of the accused had denied their presence inside the house when the incident occurred. Jadhav had, in fact, maintained that he was with his wife when she suffered the alleged seizure and had lodged a police report on the same lines.

"The accused cannot remain silent or offer a false explanation under the pretext that the burden of proof lies entirely with the prosecution," the Bench observed.

It held that Jadhav's failure to explain his wife's death, coupled with the false defence contradicted by medical evidence, provided an additional incriminating link completing the chain of circumstantial evidence and establishing his guilt for murder.

The Court also examined the statutory presumption of dowry death under Section 113B of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (Section 118 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023).

It pointed out that when a woman dies an unnatural death within seven years of marriage and it is established that she was subjected to cruelty or harassment in connection with dowry demands soon before her death, the statutory presumption of dowry death is triggered.

The burden then shifts to the accused to rebut the presumption through cogent evidence.

The Bench found that Jadhav, his father Digambar and brother Venkat had failed to rebut the presumption, particularly in view of the persistent harassment and physical cruelty established by the prosecution.

Court also reiterated that Section 106 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (Section 109 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023), places a burden on persons having exclusive knowledge of the circumstances in which an offence takes place inside a private dwelling to explain how it occurred.

The trial court, by its September 12, 1998 judgment, had convicted Jadhav, his father Digambar and brother Venkat under Sections 498-A and 304-B read with Section 34 of the IPC (Sections 85 and 86, Section 80 and Section 3(5) of the BNS, respectively). They were sentenced to one year and seven years of imprisonment, respectively, and acquitted of the murder charge.

The Bombay High Court subsequently overturned Jadhav's acquittal for murder, convicted him under Section 302 of the IPC (Section 103(1) of the BNS) and sentenced him to life imprisonment. It also upheld the convictions of the other two accused for cruelty and dowry death.

Before the Supreme Court, Digambar and Venkat argued that they had been implicated merely because of their familial relationship with Jadhav, without any specific role being attributed to them in the alleged harassment.

The State opposed the appeals, contending that the medical evidence conclusively established death by throttling and that Jadhav's false explanation further strengthened the prosecution's case.

Finding no reason to interfere with the high court's judgment, the Supreme Court dismissed the appeals and directed the appellants, who were out on bail, to surrender within four weeks to serve the remaining period of their sentences.

Case Title: Ramkishan Digambar Jadhav Vs State of Maharashtra 

Bench: Justices Sandeep Mehta and Devendra Kumar Upadhyaya 

Date of Judgment: November 02, 2026

Tags: