Lawyers Must Write For The Common Man, Not Just For Each Other: SG Tushar Mehta At “Freedom On Trial” Book Launch

Solicitor General of India Tushar Mehta on Friday said there has long been a “curse” on the legal profession, which writes on subjects that the common man is simply not interested in, while praising a new generation of young lawyers who are now writing on subjects that interest everyone.

Speaking at the launch of Freedom on Trial: Twelve Cases That Shaped India’s Struggle for Freedom, authored by Akash Bhattacharya, Mehta said lawyers have often been “pseudo intellectual” in their choice of subjects. He cited The Case for Ram by Sridhar Potaraju as another example of a lawyer writing on a subject of wide public interest.

“Not just twelve trials, but a book showing defiance”

Mehta said the book should not be read merely as twelve chapters describing twelve trials. “This is the book showing defiance. This is the book showing the rebellion,” he said, adding that each rebellion came in a different form, whether that of Lokmanya Tilak, Mahatma Gandhi or Khudiram Bose.

“In the era where we have many rebels without a cause, this book gives us the story of rebels with a very good cause,” he said. He added that the series describes what the country paid to get the Constitution it has today.

One thread, he said, runs through all these figures. They had every opportunity to bow down and enjoy the good books of the British, but chose defiance because they saw it as their duty to protect the motherland.

He recounted an incident from Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel’s time in Sabarmati Central Jail. When Mahadev Desai and Acharya Kripalani asked how the British were treating him, Patel replied sarcastically that he was convinced of British “sense of justice” because they treated him just as they treated any thief or robber. When the jailer offered a razor on condition that it be returned after use, Patel refused to be grateful, Mehta said. He quoted Patel as saying that Indians can do their own daily work and do not need barbers, unlike the British.

Defiance inside the courtroom

Turning to lawyers, Mehta asked the audience to imagine an Indian lawyer arguing before a British judge, where “your career depends upon whether you are pleasing the judge or not”, and yet choosing to be defiant.

He narrated that when Rashbehari Ghosh once arrived in court with a large stack of books, the British judge remarked that he seemed to have brought the entire library. Ghosh replied, “I thought I might try and teach some British law to you.”

Mehta also referred to Bhulabhai Desai’s defence in the Indian National Army trials. When told that fighting one’s own government was a crime, Desai reminded the court that the British Parliament had itself removed a king from office. “If your Parliament can throw out the king when you have a monarchy, why can a citizen not fight against an empire which is imposed upon my country?” Mehta quoted him as asking, calling it a remark that took even more courage coming from a lawyer.

He also recalled the trial of Khudiram Bose for the attempt on Judge Kingsford. Asked by the judge whether he wished to say anything further, the young Bose reportedly offered to explain how to make bombs if the judge had time.

“Read like a novel”

On why the book matters, Mehta said the subject is difficult because the material has been written and rewritten in many forms over a hundred years. He credited the author for writing it “in the style as if you are reading a novel” without compromising on historical facts, so that any common man, lawyer or not, would enjoy it.

“It is our responsibility as lawyers to present such work to a common man,” he said, so that people understand “we have not got the independence for asking.”

He urged the audience not only to read the book but to recommend it to at least ten friends who are not lawyers, so that they know the price the country paid for fundamental rights and the constitutional framework.

“These are the roots based upon which the Constitution has grown as a tree under which all of us feel protected,” he said.

Event Name: Book Launch of Freedom on Trial

Event Date: November 20, 2026

Tags: