Supreme Court seeks Registry's explanation after ED appeal lay unlisted for over three years.

The Supreme Court on Friday called its own Registry to account over an appeal by the Enforcement Directorate (ED) that had remained pending without being listed for over three years, even though notice was issued in September 2023 and the Court had passed successive orders for the matter to be relisted, including for final hearing or disposal. The Court directed its Secretary General to conduct a fact-finding inquiry and submit a report on why the matter had not been listed in terms of the earlier orders.

The Bench of Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana was hearing the ED's challenge to the anticipatory bail granted to businessman Raman Singhal (also referred to as Raman Singla) in a money laundering case arising out of an alleged ₹155.21-crore bank fraud. While it ordered the inquiry, the Bench declined to interfere with the bail, noting that the trial had since commenced and eight witnesses had already been examined.

At the outset, the Chief Justice sought to know why the appeal had been allowed to lie dormant year after year.

"Why has this matter not been listed? September 2023, September 2024, September 2025, September 2026. This is what I want to know," CJI Surya Kant asked.

Justice Bagchi was equally pointed. "This is nothing but institutional lethargy," he remarked.

When Senior Advocate Siddhartha Dave, appearing for Singhal, suggested that the matter may not have been listed because Benches were not available, the Chief Justice responded, "All Benches are available."

Dave then submitted, "Maybe because the Benches changed. It happens, my Lord. In a lot of matters, we try to get them listed."

The Chief Justice was not persuaded. "Nobody mentioned it? The Registry should explain why the matter was not listed in terms of the earlier order," he said.

Dave, though appearing for the respondent who stood to benefit from the delay, said that such a situation ought not to arise in the Supreme Court and that the Registry "can't be managed like that." He added that he had "never seen this happen in the Supreme Court."

This drew a retort from Senior Advocate Zoheb Hossain, appearing for the ED. "Maybe because you have not been in the Supreme Court Registry," Hossain said.

"I have been here twice the number of years you have practised, Mr Hossain," Dave replied.

"As an Advocate-on-Record I mean," Hossain clarified.

Dave was unmoved. "Since 1990, I have been practising. Justice Mohana has also practised here. Justice Bagchi and the Hon'ble Chief Justice have also been here… Don't quibble with me about all these things. I am only saying these things don't happen," he said.

The Bench was informed that the trial had commenced and that eight witnesses had already been examined. In view of the stage of the trial, the Court declined to entertain the ED's appeal and disposed of it without interfering with the anticipatory bail.

Hossain thereafter requested that the High Court's order not be treated as a precedent. Acceding to the request, the Court clarified, "The impugned order shall neither be treated as a precedent nor shall have any impact on the outcome of the trial."

Background

The appeal arose from a 30 January 2023 order of the Punjab and Haryana High Court granting anticipatory bail to Singhal in a money laundering case concerning an alleged ₹155.21-crore bank fraud involving Mahesh Timbers Private Limited.

The ED's case is that the company fraudulently enhanced Foreign Letters of Credit (FLCs) and transferred the proceeds to Amazon Exports Pte Ltd, a Singapore-based company of which Singhal was a director. The agency alleged that the transactions caused a loss of ₹155.21 crore to the bank, and arrayed Singhal as an accused, along with others, in its money laundering prosecution.

While granting anticipatory bail, the High Court took note of the fact that the ED had already filed its prosecution complaint, and that the agency had stated that Singhal could not be arrested at that stage without a warrant from the trial court.

The ED approached the Supreme Court in May 2023. Notice was issued in September 2023, and the Court subsequently passed several orders directing that the matter be relisted, including for final hearing or disposal. The appeal was nonetheless not taken up for effective hearing until Friday.

Case Title: Directorate of Enforcement v. Raman Singhal @ Raman Singla

Bench: Chief Justice of India Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V Mohana
Hearing date: November 20, 2026
Tags: