Library relocation matter goes to the CJI over roster, while the undertaking not to shift the books stays in force

The Supreme Court on Friday directed that the suo motu matter concerning the relocation of a 135-year-old library and its collection of nearly 8.5 lakh books be placed before the Chief Justice of India on the administrative side, for listing before the appropriate Bench.

Justice Sanjay Kumar observed that the subject was not part of the roster now assigned to him. The Court also recorded the Centre's statement that its undertaking of 16 November, under which the library would not be shifted, would remain in force until the next date of hearing.

Before passing the procedural order, the Court made clear that its concern lay with the books themselves. Justice Kumar said, "We are way more concerned about these books."

Justice Kumar referred once again to the photographs placed before the Court at the last hearing, which showed books lying in cartons. He remarked, "We are more concerned about these books. Look at those photographs… Those have just been thrown like that. We found a place for that. And those books are just lying there. What is to happen?"

The judge stressed that heritage cannot be reduced to buildings alone, and that the rare material in the collection, some of it said to date back to the 17th century, had to be protected.

"Heritage is not just a Newton's bungalow. Is it not? We need to look at these books. Seventeen... one book dates back to 17... something like that. We need to treasure those," Justice Kumar remarked.

To illustrate what is at stake when such a collection is lost, Justice Kumar recalled the fire at the Hyderabad High Court library in 2009, and how deeply the loss of its historic collection had affected the then Chief Justice, Justice Anil Ramesh Dave. "Chief Justice Anil Ramesh Dave cried literally. He had tears in his eyes because we lost those books. That is how much we treasured those books," he said.

Solicitor General Tushar Mehta agreed with the sentiment and cited the example of the ancient library at Nalanda to underline that the loss of such collections cannot be undone. "It's a treasure which we lose. We are conscious. The government is conscious," the SG submitted.

Before the parties made any submissions, Justice Kumar explained that the matter had been taken up suo motu, with information to the office of the Chief Justice of India. He noted, however, that the subject matter did not fall within his present roster, and that the matter should therefore be placed before the Chief Justice for listing before the appropriate Bench.

When the Solicitor General said that the Centre had no objection, Justice Kumar replied, "Let's follow the procedure. You know what happened recently."

The Solicitor General said that he understood. Justice Kumar then indicated that the matter might well return to the same Bench, but that the authorities would have to hold back in the meantime, "It may come back to me in all probability but in the meanwhile you will have to stay your hands."

He added that if the authorities had any urgency, they were free to mention the matter before the Chief Justice, or else stand by what had been stated earlier.

Solicitor General Mehta confirmed that the Centre's earlier statement would continue, and said that the Amicus Curiae and the officers concerned would sit together to find a solution within a day or two. "My earlier statement continues. I had a word with the amicus. All of us will sit together along with the officers. We will find a way out," he submitted before the Court.

Together with Additional Solicitor General (ASG) Aishwarya Bhati, the Solicitor General assured the Court that the undertaking given on behalf of the respondents on 16 November would remain in force until the next date of hearing.

Conclusively, the Court directed that the matter be listed before the Chief Justice on the administrative side for listing before the appropriate Bench. It recorded the ASG's fair statement, on behalf of the respondents, that the earlier undertaking of 16 November would continue.

A party-in-person asked that his appearance be recorded. The Court declined, and asked him to respect its earlier directions. Justice Kumar said, "Why do you need your presence to be recorded? You're not a counsel... We'll hear you in case the matter comes back to us. We are not dealing with it."

In October, the Court had sought a detailed affidavit from the Centre setting out the proposed layout and space allocation for the 135-year-old Central Secretariat Library (CSL) in Delhi.

Background

The Central Secretariat Library, spread over four floors in Shastri Bhavan, houses more than 8.5 lakh books, including rare books, official records and gazetteers. It also receives visitors including government officials and students preparing for competitive examinations. The library's oldest book, kept in a separate rare books section, is a compilation of writings by a French traveller dating back to 1702.

The proposed relocation followed a September 17 communication from the Central Public Works Department to ministries and departments housed in Shastri Bhavan, asking them to vacate the complex along with furniture, electronic items and other belongings at the earliest. The CPWD said the building had to be handed over by the end of September 2026 for commencement of construction work.

According to reports, the Directorate of Estates had in January allotted two rooms measuring around 300 square metres at Kartavya Bhavan-2 for the Central Secretariat Library. The Ministry of Culture, which administers the library, had reportedly rejected the proposed space as inadequate.

Case Title: In Re: 135 year old library, 8.5 lakh books - and no room in the New Central Vista Plan

Bench: Justices Sanjay Kumar and Sanjeev Sachdeva

Hearing Date: November 20, 2026

Tags: