Marital Rape Exception Under Section 63 BNS: Supreme Court To Hear Challenge In December
| Supreme Court deferred the batch challenging a husband's immunity from rape prosecution under the IPC and Section 63 of the BNS because it was busy with a part-heard case, and said it would try to hear the matter before the winter break begins on December 21
Supreme Court to hear the marital rape exception challenge on December 9 or 10, before the winter break
The Supreme Court on Thursday said it would take up for final hearing on December 9 or December 10 the batch of petitions questioning whether a husband can claim immunity from prosecution for raping his adult wife.
The bench of Chief Justice Surya Kant, Justices Joymalya Bagchi and V Mohana could not reach the matter during the day, as it was occupied with a part-heard case listed at 2 pm.
Senior Advocate Indira Jaising, who appears in the matter, pointed out to the bench that it was due to resume a part-heard case at 2 pm and that the marital rape batch was therefore unlikely to be reached. She asked that the batch be listed for hearing in December instead.
The Chief Justice agreed that Thursday was not feasible and offered two windows. "We will either have it on December 2-3 or on December 9-10. Today, it is not possible. We are trying to finish the part-heard matter today," the CJI said.
When one of the counsel in the case asked for the later dates, the bench obliged. "We will fix it on December 9 or December 10," it said, adding, "We will try to hear it before the winter break". The Supreme Court's winter break begins on December 21.
Exception 2 to Section 63 BNS
At the heart of the batch is the marital exception to the offence of rape. Under the exception to Section 375 of the Indian Penal Code, sexual intercourse or sexual acts by a man with his wife, where the wife is not a minor, did not amount to rape.
The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, which replaced the IPC, retains the immunity. Exception 2 to Section 63 of the BNS states that "sexual intercourse or sexual acts by a man with his own wife, the wife not being under eighteen years of age, is not rape".
The BNS, the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita and the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam came into force on July 1, 2024, replacing the IPC, the Code of Criminal Procedure and the Indian Evidence Act. The Supreme Court had sought the Centre's response on the petitions against the IPC provision on January 16, 2023, and later issued notice on a separate plea challenging the corresponding BNS provision.
On September 9, the Centre had told the bench that the counter affidavit it had already filed in the lead case could be treated as its reply in the remaining petitions as well. The bench had then indicated the two questions it would examine: whether a prosecution can be sustained if the marital rape exception survives, and whether the exception itself is constitutionally valid.
Background
In 2024, former Chief Justice of India, DY Chandrachud had expressed his inability to conclude the hearing in the petitioner in a timely manner and had listed them before a fresh bench. "Will striking down the exception and criminalizing acts of non-consensual intercourse within marriage would have the possibility of destabilizing the institution of marriage?", the court had earlier asked as the hearing had commenced.
Central government has opposed before the Supreme Court a plea for criminal martial rape, saying a comprehensive, and holistic rather than a strictly legal approach was required in the matter. In an affidavit, the government highlighted that striking down exception to husband from the offence of rape on the ground of its constitutional validity will have a far-reaching effect on the institution of marriage and may severely impact conjugal relationship.
The relationship of marriage creates an intelligible differentia which has a rational nexus with the object sought to be achieved, it said. "The concept of marriage, across personal law and jurisdictions, once solemnised as per the prevailing societal rituals or legal requirements, creates reciprocal legal and social obligations on part of both individuals. It is submitted that at the same time, marriage creates social and legal rights on the part of both individuals and others in the family, in various domains of civil laws and even criminal law," Centre added.
Petitions before Supreme Court
Supreme Court had issued notice in September 2023 in an appeal filed against the split verdict pronounced by the Delhi High Court in the cases pertaining to the issue of criminalization of marital rape. Said appeal has been filed by one Khushboo Saifi who was a petitioner before the High Court in the matter. Supreme Court while issuing notice in the plea challenging the Delhi High Court's split verdict, had also issued notices in similarly placed appeals filed by Hridaya Nest of Family Harmony and All India Democratic Women’s Association.
Saifi had approached the top court after the high court bench consisting of Justice Rajiv Shakdher and Justice C Hari Shankar granted a certificate of leave to appeal before the Supreme Court as the matter involved a substantial question of law. While Justice Shakdher had held the provision unconstitutional and ordered the exception to be struck down, Justice Harishankar had held that the provision is constitutional and is based on “intelligible differentia”.
RIT Foundation, NGO is also before Supreme Court, that initiated the principal constitutional challenge before the Delhi High Court in 2015. All India Democratic Women's Association (AIDWA), a women's rights organisation, is supporting the challenge to the marital rape exception.
Hrishikesh Sahoo is another important individual petitioner whose case reached the Supreme Court. In 2017, Sahoo's wife had filed a complaint against her husband, accusing him of multiple offences under the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC), including rape, cruelty and making threats of causing harm. He was also accused of abusing their daughter and was charged with sexual assault under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 (POSCO).
While the case was pending at the Sessions Court, Sahoo filed a writ petition at the Karnataka High Court. He invoked the ‘marital rape exception’ in the IPC and pled for the charges against him to be dropped. On 23 February 2022, Justice M. Nagaprasanna rejected Sahoo’s plea. The High Court relied on the the Justice J.S. Verma Committee report (2013) which recommended deleting the marital rape exception. It held that the exception was regressive and violated the right to equality by treating the wife as subordinate to her husband. The High Court held, “no exception under law can be so absolute that it becomes a license for the commission of a crime against society”. Sahoo then filed a Special Leave Petition at the Supreme Court of India on 10 May 2022, challenging the High Court’s decision.
Case Title: Hrishikesh Sahoo v. State of Karnataka; Youth for Equality, AIDWA Vs UOI
Bench: CJI Kant, Justice Bagchi and Justice Mohana
Hearing Date: November 19, 2026