Supreme Court says criminal law cannot enforce commercial liabilities.

The Supreme Court has held that courts must exercise caution while considering bail applications and should not assume an adversarial role against the accused, observing that criminal proceedings cannot be used as a strong-arm tactic to enforce civil liabilities arising from financial or commercial transactions.

A Bench of Justices J B Pardiwala and K Vinod Chandran made the observation while granting anticipatory bail to Mukesh Kumar alias Mukesh Kumar Sarraf, after finding that a commercial dispute over a property transaction appeared to have been converted into criminal proceedings.

The petitioner had approached the Supreme Court challenging a May 7, 2026 order of the Patna High Court, which rejected his anticipatory bail application in connection with a 2024 FIR registered at Buxar Nagar Police Station, Bihar, for offences under Sections 406, 420, 467, 468, 471 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code [Sections 316(2), 318(4), 338, 336(3), 340(2) read with Section 3(5) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023] and Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.

The complainant alleged that he had paid an advance of Rs 60 lakh to the petitioner and other co-accused persons for purchasing a property. However, upon making inquiries, he discovered that the property was disputed and subject to several legal issues.

The complainant subsequently demanded a refund of the amount. In response, the petitioner issued five cheques of Rs 12 lakh each, totalling Rs 60 lakh. However, all five cheques were dishonoured when presented for encashment, leading to the registration of the FIR.

Before the Supreme Court, the petitioner's counsel challenged the high court's order on several grounds. These included the alleged lack of jurisdiction in invoking Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act in an FIR registered and investigated by the police, an unexplained delay of more than three years in registering the FIR, and the contention that the dispute arose out of financial transactions and monetary dealings that were essentially civil in nature.

The Supreme Court found that the single judge of the high court had, regretfully, "gone overboard" while rejecting the anticipatory bail application.

It noted that the high court had observed that the petitioner appeared to be involved in large-scale monetary transactions and, on that basis, directed the Income Tax Department and the Sales Tax Department to furnish details of the taxes assessed and paid by him before the district court.

Disapproving of this direction, the Bench said that even the State did not support it.

"While considering bail applications, the High Court should either allow it or reject it and there is no point in making such order involving tax departments, who have a robust mechanism in place to find out evasion and curb it as also compensate the State by mulcting tax, interest and penalty," the Bench observed.

The Bench emphasised that while considering bail applications, courts are concerned primarily with the culpability of the accused and should not assume an adversarial role against them unless the case discloses an apparent and compelling circumstance warranting such an approach.

"In the present case, we prima facie find that a commercial transaction was attempted to be converted into criminal liability," the Bench held.

The respondents' counsel argued that the petitioner's criminal antecedents should also be taken into consideration.

However, the Supreme Court noted that the case essentially involved money advanced for the purchase of a property, secured by blank cheques that were subsequently dishonoured with the endorsement "insufficient funds".

It further pointed out that it had not been informed of any proceedings under the Negotiable Instruments Act or any civil suit having been instituted for recovery of the amount.

In these circumstances, the Bench said it could not but prima facie conclude that the initiation of criminal proceedings was "a strong arm tactic".

"On a prima facie consideration of the material on record, we are of the opinion that the petitioner can be granted anticipatory bail," the Bench said.

The Supreme Court directed that, in the event of his arrest in connection with the offences, the petitioner be released on bail subject to such terms and conditions as the investigating officer may deem fit to impose and his continued cooperation with the investigation.

It further directed that, upon being released on bail, the petitioner would appear before the jurisdictional court, namely the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Buxar, in response to any direction issued by the investigating officer or summons issued by the court, furnish bail bonds and ensure his appearance during the trial.

Case Title: Mukesh Kumar @ Mukesh Kumar Sarraf Vs State of Bihar

Bench: Justices J B Pardiwala and K Vinod Chandran 

Date of Judgment: October 30, 2026

Tags: