Non-Compliance of Restitution Decree Must Be Pleaded to Claim Divorce, MP High Court Tells Husband

The Madhya Pradesh High Court has ruled that a husband who has already won a decree for restitution of conjugal rights cannot rush to seek divorce on the ground of desertion before one year passes from that decree, as it undercuts his claim of wanting to resume married life.

A Division Bench of Justice Anand Pathak and Justice Ramkumar Choubey at Jabalpur dismissed a first appeal filed by Lomesh Kumar Bahetwar against a Family Court order of July 26, 2024, which had refused him divorce from his wife, Sarita Bahetwar. The judgment was delivered on October 29, 2026.

The couple married on December 7, 2009, in Kohka, Gondia (Maharashtra), and had two children. Their son died in May 2021 after an illness. According to the husband, the wife went to her parental home with their daughter in June 2021 and refused to return. He sought divorce on grounds of cruelty, desertion and adultery under Section 13(1) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955.

Significantly, the divorce petition was filed on September 12, 2023, when an ex parte decree for restitution of conjugal rights, passed on July 1, 2023, was already in place. Neither the decree nor its alleged non-compliance was pleaded as a ground for divorce.

Two Remedies, Two Boats

The bench was blunt about this sequence. It observed that the husband “appears to have attempted to sail in two boats at the same time”, first obtaining a decree to bring his wife back and then seeking divorce on desertion before the statutory period of one year had run out.

Relying on Tulsa Bai v. Rajendra Singh, the court explained that a spouse who obtains a restitution decree demonstrates an intention to resume cohabitation. Filing for divorce within a year of that decree “does, by itself, negate” that intention.

The court clarified that a decree-holder need not first seek execution, since compliance rests on the other spouse. Even so, the husband had to let the one-year period elapse.

The husband also sought to place the restitution decree on record at the appellate stage under Order XLI Rule 27 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The court rejected this, noting that the document was within his knowledge from the start and that no amendment to the petition was ever sought. “No evidence can be looked into without relevant pleadings,” the bench reiterated. It added that the passage of the one-year period during the appeal “cannot cure the absence of the requisite pleadings.”

On the remaining grounds, the court found no pleading or “even an iota of evidence” of adultery. On cruelty, it noted that the husband’s testimony did not state specific facts, and that what he described appeared to be “ordinary wear and tear of married life”.

On desertion, the bench stressed that living separately is not enough. The petitioner must prove the other spouse left without reasonable cause and intended to end cohabitation permanently, since desertion is “a withdrawal not from a place, but from a state of things”. The couple had lived together for years, and the wife left while in “considerable mental anguish” after losing their son. His letter, counselling-centre application and police complaint were never produced before the Family Court.

The wife did not contest the case before either court. The bench held that this did not help the husband, because Section 23(1) of the Act requires courts to be satisfied that a ground exists “whether defended or not”. Her silence, it said, “is not, by itself, treated as proof of the appellant’s case.”

While dismissing the appeal, the court clarified that the ground of non-compliance with the restitution decree was never examined on merits. The husband remains at liberty to pursue the remedy available under Section 13(1A)(ii) of the Act, in accordance with law, once the statutory requirements are fulfilled.

Advocate Atul Shukla appeared for the appellant-husband, while none appeared for the respondent-wife despite service of notice.

Case Title: Lomesh Kumar Bahetwar vs. Smt. Sarita Bahetwar

Judgment Date: October 29, 2026

Bench: Justice Anand Pathak and Justice Ramkumar Choubey

Tags: