The Bombay High Court on November 18 quashed the prosecution sanction granted by ICICI Bank’s Board of Directors to prosecute its former Managing Director and CEO, Chanda Kochhar, in the alleged ICICI-Videocon loan case.

The Court held that the Board was not the competent authority to grant sanction under Section 19 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 (PC Act), and that the power rested with the Reserve Bank of India (RBI).

Justice Milind N. Jadhav also found that the Board had failed to independently apply its mind to the material collected by the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) before granting sanction. The Court held that the sanction order dated May 15, 2023, was "unsustainable in law being a nullity" and set it aside, along with consequential actions taken by the Special CBI Court.

RBI, Not ICICI Bank Board, Was Competent To Grant Sanction

Kochhar had challenged the sanction granted by ICICI Bank’s Board under Section 19(1)(c) of the PC Act, which requires previous sanction from the authority competent to remove the public servant from office before a court can take cognizance of specified offences.

Her principal contention was that, as the former Managing Director and CEO of a banking company, the authority competent to remove her was the RBI under the Banking Regulation Act, 1949, and not ICICI Bank’s Board.

The CBI opposed the plea, arguing that the Board could appoint and remove the Managing Director under the Companies Act, 2013 and ICICI Bank’s Articles of Association. It further contended that the RBI’s power to remove senior bank officials was in addition to, and not in derogation of, the powers vested in the Board.

Rejecting the CBI’s argument, the Court relied on Sections 5-A, 35-B(1)(b), 36-AA and 36-AC of the Banking Regulation Act. It held that the provisions of the Banking Regulation Act override contrary provisions in a banking company’s memorandum or articles of association, resolutions of its Board and other applicable laws.

The Court noted that Section 36-AA empowers the RBI to remove a Chairman, Director or CEO of a banking company by an order, for reasons recorded in writing. Section 35-B(1)(b), meanwhile, requires the RBI’s previous approval for the appointment, reappointment or termination of appointment of a Managing Director or CEO.

Justice Jadhav observed: "Thus the power of removal vests with RBI and RBI only."

The Court further noted that Section 36-AA(2) provides the concerned officer a reasonable opportunity to make a representation to the RBI against a proposed removal.

In this context, it held that the Board of Directors could not exercise the statutory power vested in the RBI and consequently could not grant the prosecution sanction under Section 19(1)(c) of the PC Act.

The Court observed that the CBI ought to have approached the RBI for sanction instead of seeking it from ICICI Bank’s Board.

It held: "The Board of Directors of ICICI Bank cannot be the authority competent to remove the Petitioner, and therefore accord sanction for prosecution."

The Court also rejected the CBI’s argument that Kochhar was precluded from disputing the Board’s competence because her petition referred to it as the competent authority. It observed that "no party can claim estoppel against statutes" and that an admission cannot override applicable statutory provisions.

Sanction Order Also Suffered From Non-Application Of Mind

Apart from the Board’s lack of competence, the Court found that the sanction order suffered from a complete failure to apply mind to the material collected during the investigation.

It noted that the CBI had forwarded its request letter and report to the Board, but the underlying material gathered during the investigation was not placed before it for independent consideration.

The Court observed that the sanction order did not discuss witness statements, exhibits or documents showing Kochhar’s alleged involvement in the offences under the PC Act. Nor did the Board’s meeting minutes disclose any meaningful examination of the evidence against her.

Relying on the Supreme Court’s decision in CBI v. Ashok Kumar Aggarwal, the Court reiterated that granting sanction is not a mere formality. The entire relevant record, including material that may favour the accused, must be placed before the sanctioning authority, which must independently scrutinise it.

Applying this principle, Justice Jadhav held that the Board had granted sanction merely on the basis of the CBI’s allegations and report, without examining the supporting material or recording reasons.

The Court remarked: "There is not an ounce of evidence to show that the sanctioning authority considered any material collected by Respondent No.1, if any, in its investigation of Petitioner."

It further observed that there was "not a whisper of any discussion on the evidence against Petitioner" in either the Board’s meeting minutes or the sanction order.

Validity Of Sanction Could Be Examined At Threshold

The CBI had argued that any challenge concerning non-application of mind or the validity of the sanction should be examined during trial, after the parties had an opportunity to lead evidence.

The Court rejected this submission, distinguishing between a defective sanction and the complete absence of a valid sanction granted by the competent authority.

Referring to Section 19(3) and (4) of the PC Act and the Supreme Court decisions in Abdul Wahab Ansari v. State of Bihar and Nanjappa v. State of Karnataka, the Court held that the question of whether the sanction had been granted by a legally competent authority was a jurisdictional issue that could be decided at the threshold.

It observed that a valid sanction under Section 19(1) is a condition precedent for the Special Court to take cognizance of the relevant offences.

The Court held: "Absence of a valid sanction being a jurisdictional fact goes to the root of the matter and is an issue of law to be decided at the threshold."

It further remarked that a public servant cannot be compelled to undergo a trial where the prosecution is founded on a sanction that is void from the beginning.

Sanction Quashed; CBI's Request For Stay Rejected

The Court also took note of the position reflected in the sanction order and Board meeting minutes that ICICI Bank’s policies and procedures had not been violated in the disbursement of the loans and that no wrongful loss had been caused to the Bank. It observed that the CBI could not adopt a position contrary to the Bank’s recorded stand in this regard.

Ultimately, Justice Jadhav concluded that the sanction dated May 15, 2023, was illegal because it had been granted by an incompetent authority and the Board had completely failed to apply its mind to the material placed before it.

The Court quashed the sanction and set aside the consequential actions taken by the Special CBI Court.

After the judgment was pronounced, the CBI sought a stay of its operation for eight weeks to enable it to challenge the decision. The Court declined the request.

Case Title: Chanda Kochhar v Central Bureau of Investigation & Anr.

Tags: