The Delhi High Court on November 18 asked the Ministry of Home Affairs (MHA) to examine social media videos allegedly showing suspended Assistant Commissioner of Police (ACP) Manasvi Vashishta making threatening and derogatory remarks against lawyers, and consider their removal if warranted.

A Division Bench comprising Acting Chief Justice Nitin Wasudeo Sambre and Justice Sanjay Sharma was hearing a Public Interest Litigation (PIL) filed by advocate Karan Bir Singh, seeking action against police personnel over alleged threats, intimidation and public vilification of members of the legal profession.

The Court directed the petitioner to provide the relevant videos and other material to the Central Government within 48 hours. The MHA was also asked to examine the social media accounts from which the content was being circulated.

The Bench also issued notice to Vashishta, another police official identified as Vikas Yadav, and the MHA, directing them to file their responses within four weeks. The petitioner has been granted two weeks thereafter to file a rejoinder.

MHA informs Court of suspension, proposed departmental action against Vashishta

During the hearing, counsel appearing for the MHA informed the Court that Vashishta had been suspended on November 2 and that a chargesheet against him had been submitted to the Ministry for consideration and approval.

The Centre's counsel further stated that a status report would be filed before the Court within four weeks.

Regarding the videos allegedly uploaded through the social media accounts of the police officials, the MHA submitted that the content would be examined once the petitioner supplied the relevant material. Appropriate steps would be taken for removal of the objectionable content, if required.

The Court accordingly permitted the petitioner to furnish the material within 48 hours to enable the Government to examine it and take appropriate action.

PIL flags alleged AK-47 threat against advocate

The petition alleges that serving Delhi Police personnel made threatening and derogatory statements against lawyers amid the recent confrontation between the police and the legal fraternity.

It refers to videos allegedly showing Vashishta making disparaging remarks about advocates, including a statement suggesting that five lawyers entering a police station together could be treated as an unlawful assembly and detained.

The plea also refers to a separate video allegedly showing Sub-Inspector Vishal Yadav threatening to fire an AK-47 rifle at an advocate if the latter laid hands on him.

The petitioner has argued that the alleged statements raise concerns regarding criminal intimidation, misuse of official authority and the safety of lawyers while discharging their professional duties.

Apart from seeking removal of specifically identified videos and publications from social media platforms, the PIL seeks preservation of the original electronic evidence, an independent and time-bound inquiry into the alleged misconduct, and appropriate criminal and departmental proceedings against the police personnel concerned.

The petition also seeks institutional safeguards to protect the professional independence, dignity and safety of advocates.

PIL follows police protest outside Delhi Police Headquarters

The petition was filed in the aftermath of the November 2 demonstration by Delhi Police personnel outside the force's headquarters, reportedly led by Vashishta, following his transfer in connection with the confrontation between lawyers and police personnel at Shahdara Police Station.

The dispute had escalated after advocate Lalit Bansal allegedly sustained a serious head injury during an altercation on October 23. Lawyers subsequently launched an indefinite strike, alleging that Vashishta and the Station House Officer of Shahdara Police Station, Arun Kumar, had threatened them when they approached the police station over the handling of the assault case.

The lawyers demanded action against the officers concerned. Vashishta and Arun Kumar were subsequently transferred, following which police personnel assembled outside the Police Headquarters seeking a meeting with the Police Commissioner.

The PIL also contends that the participation of serving police personnel in the November 2 demonstration warrants examination under the Police Forces (Restriction of Rights) Act, 1966, and the applicable service and conduct rules.