Madras High Court Justice G.R. Swaminathan on Monday responded to criticism by CPI(M) MP Su Venkatesan over his remarks suggesting that books on spirituality be placed in a public library in place of allegedly fraudulent publications, questioning the parliamentarian's lifestyle and recalling an encounter in which he arrived at a railway station in a Mercedes-Benz.

The exchange took place during the hearing of a contempt petition concerning alleged irregularities in the procurement of books for public libraries across Tamil Nadu.

Justice Swaminathan recalled meeting Venkatesan, who represents Madurai in the Lok Sabha, at Chennai railway station around six months ago.

The judge said he had noticed a Mercedes-Benz outside the station and initially assumed that the person getting out of the car was a corporate executive, given his branded clothes and shoes.

"He claims to be a communist leader, you know? But he comes in a high-end Benz car, wears branded everything and I don't know whether the book royalties will sustain such a lifestyle," the judge remarked.

He said that he and the MP had walked towards the train together. While Venkatesan was travelling in First AC, the judge said he was proceeding to the Sleeper Class compartment.

"He said ‘Sir, Judge sir, where are you going?’ I said, ‘I normally travel by Sleeper Class. My number is S3-23’” Justice Swaminathan recalled.

Referring to Venkatesan's criticism of his remarks, the judge said: "So this...he is telling me as to what I should do as a judge."

Justice Swaminathan says spiritual-books suggestion was a joke

The exchange followed Venkatesan's post on X on November 15, in which he criticised the judge's suggestion, made at a book-release function, that books on Maha Periyava, the late Kanchi Shankaracharya, be placed in the library in place of books allegedly supplied by Agal Vilakku Publications.

Venkatesan had argued that the alleged irregularities amounted to corruption and that those responsible should be punished in accordance with law. He said that punishing corruption was the responsibility of judges, whereas prescribing atonement for sins was the work of astrologers. He also invoked B.R. Ambedkar and Periyar for their contributions to legal thought and rationalism.

Clarifying his earlier remarks during Monday's hearing, Justice Swaminathan said they were made in a lighter vein. "I just cracked a joke, okay? It was really meant to be a joke only" he said.

Explaining the suggestion, the judge remarked: "By buying these books and stacking the racks, they have committed a sin. Let them wipe away that sin by replacing them with books on spirituality."

DVAC registers FIR; proprietor of Agal Vilakku named as accused

On the substantive proceedings concerning the alleged procurement scam, State Public Prosecutor John Sathyan informed the Bench that the Directorate of Vigilance and Anti-Corruption (DVAC), Chennai City, had registered an FIR in Crime No. 4 of 2026 under various provisions of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita and the Prevention of Corruption Act.

The proprietor of Agal Vilakku Publications, Mohan, who figures prominently in the alleged scam, has been named as an accused, the Court was informed.

Advocate General Vijay Narayan told the Court that five officials had already been suspended in connection with the matter. He also assured the Bench that everyone involved would be dealt with, irrespective of their position.

"No person who was involved in this will go unpunished. That Your Lordship can be assured," he submitted.

The Bench was also informed that approximately ₹20 crore had been disbursed out of the ₹30 crore sanctioned for the procurement exercise.

Court says custodial interrogation may be necessary to trace payments to public servants

In its order, the Bench recorded nine sets of queries it had raised with the State concerning the procurement process. These included whether the conditions applicable to general procurement were also followed for the special procurement undertaken for Periyar Arivulagam; the time taken to select and procure books for Periyar Arivulagam and Kalaignar Centenary Library; and the number of books recommended, rejected and ultimately purchased.

The Court also sought details of the 137-member expert committee and questioned how Agal Vilakku's submission of over 2,300 titles resulted in the selection and procurement of around 1,700 titles, while the remaining titles were rejected.

Expressing concern over the scale and manner of the alleged irregularities, the Bench observed that it was conscious that a court should not direct an investigating officer to arrest a particular accused. However, it said the present case fell within an exceptional category.

"The bogus publishers have already been identified. Or at least some of them. Unless they are custodially interrogated, one will never know how much money was paid to which public servant. The modus operandi must be brought out," the Court observed.

It further noted that, for the first time, artificial intelligence and digital processes had been subverted to achieve what it described as sinister ends. The Court said these matters fell within the domain of the police and expressed hope that a clearer picture would emerge by the next hearing.

Court calls for White Paper on 20 years of book procurement

The Bench said the State should undertake a detailed probe and place before it, by the next hearing, a statement explaining how book procurement had taken place over the preceding 20 years. It observed that submitting a White Paper would be appropriate.

"The scam has shaken the conscience of the people of Tamil Nadu. Their faith in the system must be restored," the Court said.

The Bench also sought details of the library cess collected by the State, including whether the amounts had been duly credited and how the money had been spent. It directed the authorities to address the issue in their affidavit.

Noting that the existing guidelines had been rendered “toothless”, the Court said it was time to evolve a foolproof procedure to prevent a recurrence of such a scam. It took on record three sets of suggestions submitted by stakeholders, including publisher Badrinarayanan Seshadri of Kizhakku Pathippagam, and expected the Government to examine them carefully and respond by the next hearing.

The Advocate General submitted that the Government would consider suggestions from the Court for streamlining future procurement. The Bench indicated that once a binding procedure was put in place, it would close the contempt petition after issuing suitable directions.

The matter will be taken up on November 20.

Tags: