Mental Cruelty| Wife Telling Husband To ‘Go And Sleep With His Mother' Unacceptable: Madras High Court Upholds Divorce Decree
| Madras High Court holds wife's remark asking husband to sleep with his mother amounted to mental cruelty, upholding divorce decree.
Madras High Court held wife's indecent remark against mother-in-law caused husband mental agony.
The Madras High Court recently upheld a divorce decree granted to a husband, holding that his wife's alleged remark asking him to “go and sleep with his mother” caused mental cruelty.
The bench of Justice Dr. P. Murugan was dealing with a civil miscellaneous appeal filed by a woman seeking direction to set aside the divorce decree awarded on February 24, 2023 by the Principal District Court, Thoothukudi, to her husband on a divorce petition filed by him in 2017.
The couple got married on October 21, 1993, at St. Xavier's Church, Punnakayal, according to Christian rites and customs. They had no children from the marriage.
In 2017, the husband filed for divorce alleging that his wife repeatedly insulted him in front of others, suspected his fidelity, refused to cook for him and quarrelled with him.
He further alleged that she threatened to give his house and her 18 sovereigns of gold to her brother's children after his death and made insulting remarks about his mother. He argued that the wife's conduct over their 24-year marriage caused him considerable mental agony.
In 2017, the wife deserted him, saying that she did not want to live with him, and this pushed the husband to file for divorce.
The wife denied the allegations, describing them as false and invented. She claimed that she had always shown love and affection towards her husband, while he repeatedly tortured her. She maintained that she was willing to resume matrimonial life.
Before the high court, the wife's counsel submitted that cruelty depends on the individual circumstances and the impact of particular conduct on the person alleging cruelty. He relied on the Supreme Court judgment in Gurbux Singh v. Harminder Kaur (2010).
He contended that the expressions attributed to the wife, apart from the remark asking her husband to sleep with his mother, were commonly used in village life and did not constitute cruelty.
The wife further alleged that her husband had sold her jewellery on May 7, 2009, to purchase two cents of land, which he intended to transfer to his relatives. She also alleged that he had left her and failed to provide money for family expenses.
Taking into account the submissions made by both the sides, the high court noted that the attitude of the wife revealed that she was not respecting her husband and after sustaining mental cruelty, the husband had filed the petition for dissolving the marriage for the need of peace.
Also, after reappreciating the evidence on record, the high court held that the trial court had meticulously considered the case on both sides and finally had come to the conclusion that the act of the wife amounted to cruelty.
Importantly, court held that the expression asking the husband to go and sleep with his mother was unacceptable.
" (It) cannot be digested, particularly when uttered by a dutiful wife, as it would cause considerable mental agony to the husband. When the matter was discussed before the Panchayat, and advised the respondent (the) even then, the respondent did not show any willingness or positive attitude towards resuming matrimonial life with the petitioner," the single judge bench highlighted.
Stating that the appeal did not deserve to be allowed, as the act of the wife amounted to mental cruelty to the husband, the high court dismissed it and upheld the divorce decree.
Case Title: Amali v. Maria Antony Joseph
Order Date: November 17, 2026
Bench: Justice Dr. P. Murugan