Newspaper Reports Without Proof Have No Evidentiary Value, MP HC Tells Insurer Challenging Accident Claim
| The MP High Court held that an insurer cannot avoid a motor accident claim on a plea that the vehicle was “implanted”, when it relies on unverified newspaper clippings and an incomplete investigation report.
Unproved Newspaper Clippings Cannot Back an “Implant” Defence in Accident Claims, Says MP High Court
The Madhya Pradesh High Court has held that an insurance company cannot defeat a motor accident claim by relying on unverified newspaper clippings and a sketchy investigation report to argue that the offending vehicle was falsely “implanted” in the case. Observing that “no party can be allowed to take advantage of its own negligence,” the court dismissed the insurer’s appeal and imposed costs of Rs 10,000.
Justice Vivek Agarwal, sitting at Jabalpur, passed the order on November 16 in an appeal filed by the Manager, Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd., under Section 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. The insurer had challenged an award dated March 31, 2022, passed by the Fourth Additional Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Sagar, in MACC No. 159/2019, filed by Smt. Rajju Raje and others.
The accident took place on August 15, 2018, at about 8 pm, and the deceased was Jitendra Singh. The inquest (merg) was recorded at 12:15 am on August 16, 2018, and noted that the accident involved an “unknown truck”. The vehicle was seized on October 24, 2018.
The insurer pointed to the seizure date and to newspaper clippings enclosed with its investigator’s report, which suggested that the deceased had come in contact with a stray animal on the road. This, it argued, made it a case of “implant”.
Single-Page Report Did Not Help the Insurer
The insurer had examined Bhawani Shankar, a Law Officer at its Regional Office in Indore, to prove the report of investigator Surendra Gupta, marked as Ex.D-1. The High Court was unimpressed. It noted that the report ran to a single page and made no mention of any facts of the accident. It merely stated that the investigator had obtained papers pertaining to the criminal case and enclosed them, along with two newspaper clippings.
The court observed that the Law Officer could not explain how the report helped the insurer prove its case. There was also no explanation as to why the investigator himself was not examined, or why his complete report was never filed. On the other hand, the claimants had examined an eye-witness, Rajkumar, who proved the accident.
On the newspaper clippings, the court relied on the Supreme Court’s ruling in Ghanshyam Upadhyay v. State of Uttar Pradesh, which in turn referred to Kushum Lata v. Union of India. The Supreme Court had held that a newspaper item “without any further proof is of no evidentiary value”.
Applying this principle, Justice Agarwal said that “an unconfirmed newspaper report, without any verification of its authenticity, should not normally be relied upon.” The insurer, he noted, “did not bother to adduce the evidence of the news reporter” to show where the information came from or whether it was authentic. Since its main plank rested on unsubstantiated reports, the court held that “no indulgence can be shown in the matter.”
The court also pointed out that the insurer’s own counsel, while cross-examining Rajkumar, had obtained an admission about the accident along with the number of the truck. It found no effective cross-examination of the eye-witness.
The bench was particularly critical of the insurer’s conduct. It held that the company’s officers were negligent in not producing the complete investigation report, and that Ex.D-1 was “incomplete, sketchy and devoid of any details”. Neither the investigator nor the Investigating Officer of the criminal case had been examined.
The insurer, the court said, “cannot be allowed to take advantage of their own fault in not adducing proper evidence.” Concluding that the appeal “deserves to fail,” the court dismissed it. The insurer was directed to bear the claimants’ litigation costs, quantified at Rs 10,000, and the record was ordered to be sent back to the Claims Tribunal.
Case Title: Manager Shriram General Insurance Co. Ltd. vs. Smt. Rajju Raje and Others
Order Date: November 16, 2026
Bench: Justice Vivek Agarwal